Share
The text of Keynote Speech by
Luk Bouckaert
Emeritus Professor of Ethics at the Catholic University of Leuven (K.U. Leuven, Belgium) &European SPES Forum
Can Spirituality save the World?
Presented at
12th Annual GCGI International Conference and the 2nd Joint GCGI and SES Forum
The Value of Values: Spiritual Wisdom in Everyday Life”
31 August- 4 September, 2014
Waterperry House, Oxford
2014 Oxford Program 
Abstract 
Can Spirituality save the World?

Is the world driven by politics of power, economics of greed and a cultural ethos of consumerism?  At first glance, it seems that many political and economic events can be explained by these narrow drivers of individual and collective ego-centrism. However, there are countervailing powers at work.  A growing number of people from different religions, nationalities, political parties, scientific disciplines or social classes become aware that we reached the limits of our current system of ego-centric growth.  In interviews enlightened business leaders speak about their interest in Zen or other meditative practices.

In this paper I will focus on the shift from business rationality to business spirituality? Is it only a change in vocabulary or does it reveal a deeper (r)evolution? Although spirituality clearly implies an inward movement unlocking the inner self in depth, it simultaneously reconnects the self to the outer world generating a personalized sense of responsibility for the whole. How can we integrate this spiritual sensitivity in a theoretical framework that can support a sustainable and coherent managerial practice?

We will first explore some paradoxes in current economic rationality such as the ethics management paradox,  the happiness paradox and the sustainability paradox. Second, we will elucidate the distinction between rational and spiritual knowledge and explain why spiritual knowledge can help us to understand and solve these paradoxes.  In the last section I will propose some reflections for a spiritual-based theory and practice of leadership linking spirituality to the work floor of daily life.

Good morning Ladies and Gentlemen,

Can Spirituality save the world? This is not meant as rhetoric but as an open question. Answering ‘yes it can’, might sound very great but also very naïve. It is not realistic to assume that our great-grandchildren will live in a world without greed, dominance and competition. Answering ‘no’ or ‘mission impossible’ would express defeatism and make our gathering here completely redundant. By joining this conference we express at least the implicit belief that spirituality as a factor of social change can make a difference. 

Spirituality as a lever of change has a completely other modus operandi than other factors of change such as HR management, ethical codes, CSR regulations, reputation management, legal regulations, taxation policies etc.  Spirituality relates a person or an organization to its soul or to its inner self. Hence spiritual changes do not operate from external conditions and incentives but from within, from an inward movement unlocking the inner self in depth. In section 1 I will tackle the question ‘Why do we need such an inner directed movement in economic and social life’? Section 2 explains how spirituality leads to a revision of some basic concepts such as happiness or ethics. In the third section I will elaborate on the nature and source of spirituality. The last section deals with the practice of spiritual-based leadership

The paradoxes of economic life: or why we need spirituality?

We can sum up many reasons to introduce spirituality in social and economic life?  Some will stress that we live in a VUCA world: a world characterized by a high degree of Volatility, Uncertainty, Complexity and Ambiguity. Because we can no longer control such a volatile and uncertain world on the basis of econometric and rational models, we need a higher type of holistic knowledge to anticipate the future. Hence spirituality is used as a container concept for all these meta-rational forms of knowledge which we call wisdom, intuition, spiritual intelligence, meditation or mindfulness etc. and which empower us to cope with the uncertainties of the VUCA world.

Another line of argumentation starts from the observed lack of trust in organizations. The Edelman Trust Barometer gives us an idea of the decreasing trust in political, religious, social and financial institutions. Besides market failures, we are confronted with political and moral failures. Our media are full of stories of corruption, fraud, scandals and misuse. Hence, in order to give  our institutions a new credibility, we should renew their foundation.  What is mostly needed is a new type of leaders whom we can trust because of their inner integrity, inspiring vision and social empathy. Spirituality emerged in business ethics in the beginning of this century through the mediation of transformative leadership theory and practice. I will come back to this leadership practice in section 3. 

Although the arguments of the VUCA world and of trustful leadership are good entrees to introduce the need of spirituality in social life, they don’t inform as much about the kind of spirituality we need to overcome the problems of distrust and uncertainty. In my view a complementary approach is to focus on the paradoxical features of our current economic and social system. Paradoxes are problems that cannot be solved within the existing logic. They reveal an unsolvable contradiction. The only way to solve them is to transform our way of looking at things. As Einstein has reminded us: We cannot solve our problems with the same thinking we used when we created them. In this perspective spirituality can be viewed as a heuristic to solve unsolvable problems (Schumacher, 2004).[1]

We will confine us here to two paradoxes that are manifest today for many observers. They are called the ‘paradox of happiness’ and the ‘ethics management paradox’ (Bouckaert, 2007 & 2006).

The happiness paradox

The happiness paradox has a long history. Even within the utilitarian tradition the paradox was stated by John Stuart Mill, saying that people fixed on the goal of happiness will not be the happiest people. The paradox is cultivated in many spiritual traditions warning us against the illusion that more material wealth makes us more happy. In contrast with all this warnings economists are used to define happiness as the maximum utility or pleasure we can get from the realisation of all our needs and preferences given the constraints of budget and time. By economising scarce means and time, they assume that happiness will always increase.

Easterlin (1974) was the first economist to put the correlation between economic growth and happiness into question on the basis of statistical research. He found that in international comparisons, the average reported level of happiness did not vary much with national income per person, at least for countries with income sufficient to meet basic needs. Similarly, although income per person rose steadily in the United States between 1946 and 1970, average reported happiness showed no long-term trend and declined between 1960 and 1970. The self-evident correlation between growth of income and happiness was broken. The Easterlin paradox was the start of an ongoing body of research, called happiness economics. But simultaneously, it opened a philosophical debate. If it is true that more income and more welfare state do not create more happiness, why should we always strive for more economic growth, more income and more welfare state.[2]

The ethics management paradox

The ethics management paradox is based on an observation in the field of business (Bouckaert, 2006). Business ethics gained more and more attention in the eighties and nineties of the last century. One of the basic arguments in this rise of business ethics was the argument that in the long run ethics pays, hence ethics is a good investment for the company and its stakeholders. However, we can easily observe that a lot of companies or organisations involved in ethics programmes and using ethical language do not always display genuine ethical commitment once confronted with a difficult situation. An example of this in my country was the closing of a Renault plant in Brussels in the 1997. Renault at that time developed an ethos of participation and cooperation on the factory floor but, once it was confronted with a problem of long term profitability, forgot completely about its stakeholder philosophy and fired more than three thousand employees without prior communication or negotiation. This is just one example of how business ethics proclaimed on the factory floor was disclaimed on the level of decision-making. The crucial point was not that companies sometimes need to close a plant for reasons of long term profitability but the way it was done without negotiation and communication. The result of the highly discussed case in Belgium was a growing distrust of managerial ethical discourse. Other business scandals in the late nineties (Enron, Lernaut&Hauspie, Worldcom a.o.) and more recently during the banking crisis revealed the same phenomenon: more ethics management does not guarantee  more ethical commitment. Analogously to the happiness paradox teaching us that more welfare does not necessarily create more happiness, we can observe that more ethics management does not necessarily create more ethics in management.

Towards a spiritual understanding of reality

In the nineteenth century Karl Marx was convinced that a paradigm shift to scientific materialism was needed to understand and solve the contradictions of the economics of capitalism. To-day, we need a spiritual understanding of reality to solve the current contradictions of our economic system.[3] Following this argument implies that we should introduce spirituality in our concepts of happiness and ethics to understand and solve the paradoxes.

Revising happiness

Economists define happiness as the maximization of pleasure (utility) through the optimal realisation of our basic needs and preferences.  But this is only half a truth. Apart from our capability to maximise pleasure from the fulfillment of our needs and preferences, human happiness greatly depends on the quality of human relations: family relations, authentic friendship, good professional relations with colleagues and peers etc. The key point here is that the quality of human relations cannot be reduced to the economic notion of maximising pleasure. Let me illustrate it with the example of friendship. 

Defining friendship as the maximisation of pleasure drawn from an encounter with a friend would reduce the presence of my friend to a means for maximising my own happiness. Most of us will realise that such an approach is deemed to fail. A flourishing friendship needs at least a tacit commitment to keep the friendship alive even if it implies a cost in terms of pleasure. Too much focus on maximising feelings of pleasure undermines the genuine commitment of the relation. Moreover, it will reduce friendship to a consumption good submitted to the economic law of decreasing marginal utility. Our feelings of friendship will decrease and burn out (as we see in so many relations). This is exactly what the happiness paradox reveals: the more we focus upon maximising happiness as a pleasure, the less we will get it. This makes clear that the source of genuine and endurable friendship does not lay in the fulfillment of our own need of affection but in the commitment to endorse each other’s life in good and bad days. Only by this commitment beyond egocentrism can friendship escape the decreasing curb of marginal utility. 

From the example of friendship we may learn that human happiness has a dual nature. It only partly results from our rational capability of maximising pleasure. More important is the spiritual capability of self-gift and reciprocal commitment. This is not only true for friendship: all genuine human relations require a particular non egocentric commitment. If we want to restore a positive relation between happiness and economics, we have to focus on the quality of human relations. Pleasure and utility cannot be the ultimate concepts of economics. We should integrate the relational and spiritual view of happiness within economics and business.

Revising ethics

In a similar way as we unveiled the dual nature of happiness we should realise the dual nature of ethics. Ethics has, at the same time, an instrumental/rational and a non-instrumental/intrinsic meaning. Economists focusing exclusively on the instrumental or rational use of things, approaches ethics as a tool to realise some external goals such as a better reputation, lower transaction costs, reduction of risk, cooperation of stakeholders, goals which at the end can improve profit for a company.

There is nothing wrong with this rational and instrumental use of ethics as far as it does not crowd out the intrinsic and genuine meaning of ethics. Precisely this crowding out mechanism – replacing moral feelings by economic incentives – is at work in the many failures of business ethics in the IT and banking sector. It explains very well our paradox: the more (rational) ethics management, the less (genuine) ethics in management. If our ethical behavior is mainly driven by external goals and incentives, ethics will be applied in a very selective and opportunistic way and at the end be crowded out. The call for more spirituality in business and leadership is an effort to restore the balance between instrumental and intrinsic use of ethics in business.

But the difficult point here is to define what we mean by intrinsic motivation? It does not suffice to say that intrinsic motivation implies that our behavior is not driven by external goals such as good reputation, profit making or a competitive advantage. If we do not explain the nature and source of the  inner commitment, we will not understand why spirituality is needed.  For most philosophers the Kantian and rational answer will suffice. In a Kantian perspective, intrinsic motivation means that the good we want to do is good in and for itself and can be considered as a basic and necessary good for every human being.  

The Kantian definition is right but highly abstract. We can easily agree on the Kantian principles and remain selectively blind for our own unethical behavior or being morally disengaged in everyday life. Therefore, instead of a rational based ethics characterized by abstract principles and deductions, we need an experience-based approach to ethics unlocking and motivating our personal, inner self. Here spirituality as a personal search for meaning and purpose in life comes in. But to make the case of spirituality more convincing, we have to clarify what we mean by it. 

The nature and source of spirituality

Defining spirituality is not an easy task. In the SPES network[4] we define spirituality as people’s multiform search for meaning interconnecting them with all living beings and to ‘God’ or ‘Ultimate Reality’. The key word of this definition is ‘interconnecting’ and I believe that this is the hallmark for an experience based definition of spirituality. However I would like to suggest a somewhat lighter version of the SPES definition: Spirituality is a way of thinking and living that originates from deep and personal experiences of interconnectedness.   This statement focuses on two points: first, the origin of spirituality lays in deep and personal experiences of interconnectedness; second, spirituality coincides with a specific way of thinking and living. The last point is important. Without critical reflection (thinking) and concrete practices (living) spirituality runs the risk to fall in subjectivism and escapism.

Some approaches of spirituality are stressing so much the experiential and mystical part as to lose the input of critical and reflective thinking while other definitions are too philosophical and miss the personal and existential search for meaning. No less misleading is a one-sided focus on practical effects   reducing spirituality to an instrument of stress reduction, work motivation or therapeutic recovery. To give spirituality a solid foundation a good balance between inner experience, reason and practice is required.

Religion, ethics and spirituality are not the same. The three domains are different but complementary expressions of the human search for values, meaning and purpose in life. Religion keeps alive transcendent values and moral norms through institutionalized rituals, ceremonies and traditions; ethics creates values, rights and norms by education, public debate and legal regulations; spirituality discloses its values of deep interconnection through a process of inward reflection and personal search for meaning. Historically, there have been many conflicts between spiritual committed persons and established religious  and moral systems. Yet in my view spirituality remains  the inner source of religion and ethics. Religions always have been founded and renewed by spiritual leaders and ethics remain abstract without spiritual motivation and commitment. Despite bloody and cruel conflicts I believe that an ongoing process of alignment takes place between religious faith, spiritual experience and human rights ethics. 

As said, spirituality originates from deep and personal experiences of interconnectedness which are accessible for every human being. These experiences are very different from the digital and technology-driven forms of connection via internet. To some extent digital globalization disconnects people from their roots and communities. The inward search for spiritual interconnectedness may be considered as a way to cope with the negative effects of global disconnectedness. 

Experiences of spiritual interconnectedness can take many shapes and expressions but they all have in common a deep sense of being part of a greater whole or flow. Just to mention some examples[5]. On some privileged days we experience nature as an overwhelming source of life and beauty eliciting deep feelings of awe, gratitude and interconnectedness. At such moments we feel life as a gift and as a flow of co-creativity. Religious people relates this experience of life as a gift to God as the ultimate Giver. But even without religious reference we can experience ourselves as deeply part and gift of Nature. The deep ecology movement is an expression of this experience.

Another deep feeling of interconnectedness comes into being when we are confronted with the vulnerability of things – be it the defenselessness of children, the suffering of people, the voicelessness of future generations, the threatened species of animals or the vulnerability of our overexploited planet itself. Vulnerability, breaking open our comfort zone, spontaneously awakens in our mind and heart an inner sense of empathy, compassion and co-responsibility According to the French philosopher, Emmanuel Levinas, the traumatic confrontation with situations of human vulnerability is the genuine source of social ethics.

In all these experiences of interconnectedness we see a double movement at work. On the one side there is an inward movement. We are deeply touched – in our mind and heart - by a suffering face, an unexpected encounter, a challenging situation. We are not producing or making the experience in an active way. A deep experience overwhelms us. We are  in a passive but very alert modus. At that moment we coincide – be it for just a moment - with the other or with the inner flow of life.

On the other hand the dynamics of interconnectedness also reveal an ethical movement from the self to the other. In her magnificent work The Silent Cry: Mysticism and Resistance (Minneapolis, Fortress Press, 2001) Dorothée Sölle nicely demonstrates how the mystical experience of interconnectedness generates an inner call for social action to save the world. Spiritual persons are empowered to resist consumerism and opportunism and to take unexpected initiatives to ‘save the world’.

A recent example of the link between spirituality and social activism is the  provocative  essay, Time for Outrage ( Indignez-vous), a 35-page book written by Stéphane Hessel in 2010 at the age of 93. The essay sold 3 million copies in 30 languages and inspired protests like Occupy in the United States and The Indignados in Spain. Stéphane Hessel calls us to give more space to the emotion of moral indignation in order to generate concrete actions of solidarity. He wrote “The worst possible outlook is indifference that says, “I can’t do anything about it; I’ll just get by.” Behaving like that deprives you of one of the essentials of being human: the capacity and the freedom to feel outraged. That freedom is indispensable, as is the political involvement that goes with it.”

However we must be careful with feelings of moral indignation. Moral indignation runs the risk to generate feelings of vengeance and blind violence. History teaches us  that a deep spiritual experience of interconnectedness is needed to keep our moral indignation free from them. It is the greatness of leaders such as Mahatma Gandhi and Nelson Mandela to keep the emotion of moral indignation in alignment with the spirit of universal interconnectedness. By this reference to leaders such as Gandhi or Mandela  I come to my last section: the practice of spiritual-based leadership which links mysticism with social activism.   

The practice of leadership 

In current theory of leadership, the distinction between the rational manager and the value-driven leader is mostly linked to the distinction between transactional and transformative leadership  (Bass, 1990).  While the aim of transactional leadership is to motivate and direct people through rewards and punishment, transformational leadership is focused on transforming people by creating a new vision and a shared set of values in an organization. Transforming people through shared values requires a growing relation of partnership and open communication which generates trust and intrinsic motivation. Transformational leadership integrates the themes of empowerment, charisma, servant leadership and value-driven management.

However it is important to realise that within the range of transformative leadership there are many types to distinguish. Steve Jobs has been a very charismatic leader gifted with good intuitions and able to motivate people but his practice of leadership was primarily driven by market imperatives, creation of shareholder value and strict operational control. Business leaders as Lars Kolind (Oticon) or Muhammed Yunus (Grameen bank) gives more attention to the personal sense of co-responsibility and co-creativity of people and to the creation of meaning in work. Still other charismatic leaders follow an aristocratic model of leadership leading to a paternalistic and hierarchic type of governance. 

To get more grip on the ambiguities and different models within transformative leadership, we can structure the field on the basis of two axes: a vertical axe representing the tension between a market driven and a spirit centered idea of leadership, and a horizontal axe representing the tension between an aristocratic and a democratic vision of leadership. Each quadrant refers to a specific type of transformational leadership. Of course, real leaders are often a mix of the ideal types but there is always a dominant characteristic.  The key assumption of the spiritual-based model of leadership is the idea of being interconnected not only by market relations but by a primary sense of shared co-creativity and co-responsibility. Because of this spiritual link, every person has in his/her function a potential to lead and to follow. Its style of communication empowers people and fosters social relations of trust, reciprocity and interconnectedness.

Market

Market leadership                        CSR Leadership

(Shareholder value)                     (stakeholder value)

Aristocracy                                                             D       Democracy

Aristocratic leadership              Spiritual-based leadership

(top-down inspiration)                     (co-creation of meaning)

Spirit

Fig. 1 Types of transformational leadership

More challenging than making a nice typology of leadership styles, is the question how to start a practice of spiritual-based entrepreneurship and leadership? When entrepreneurs ask me where to start, I always answer that they are the starting point. In all spiritual traditions self knowledge and self transformation are the first steps to enlightenment. Without an effort of self reflection and self transformation, spiritual and ethical programmes in business will remain manipulative management tools for good reputation and  window dressing. Therefore the first step is asking oneself who I am, what is the meaning and purpose of my own life, what inspires me, how can I make good decisions? Next to this step of self-disclosure (unlocking the inner self) comes the passion for quality and, as a third step, creating conditions for co-creative communication. Within the Belgian SPES Academy we developed a series of workshops in order to facilitate these steps.

Unlocking the inner self 

To facilitate the first step, for some years already SPES organizes a workshop entitled ‘Thinkers for Doers’. The philosophy behind the workshop is that reading together a brief but well selected master text in spirituality is a more easy way for self disclosure than the method of direct introspection. We need a mirror to see ourselves in the right way. Therefore we read eye opening text fragments from the Buddhist, the Christian, the Sufi, the Socratic tradition as well as from modern philosophers and poets. All text fragments are helpful to distinguish the difference between the rational ego and the inner or spiritual self.  After a brief introduction, the participants read the text personally and in group. After this, they are invited to apply the text to their own lives and experiences.

To give an example. One of the texts I like to read in the workshop is a poem of Lao Tzu from the Tao Te Ching  (poem 48 in the translation of Stephen Mitchell, 1988).

“In pursuit of knowledge,
every day something is added.
In the practice of the Tao,
every day something is dropped.
Less and less do you need to force things,
until finally you arrive at non-action.
When nothing is done,
nothing is left undone.
True mastery can be gained
by letting things go their own way.
It can't be gained by interfering.”

The poem invites the reader to understand the distinction between the rational and the spiritual self or between rational and spiritual intelligence. In contrast to rational thinking, spiritual intelligence is presented by Lao Tzu as a process of ‘dropping every day something’ until you arrive at a stage of non-action. The process is very similar to what the Greek philosopher Socrates has in mind as the first and most fundamental prerequisite to gain wisdom: we must discover in our mind  a point of not knowing – ‘I know that I do not know’.  So the relevant question for the workshop is: do we recognise in our mind such a point prior to action and rational knowledge?  Can we trust that point of ‘spiritual intelligence’ as a source of creativity and decision making? As you can imagine, such a workshop opens a space for deep questions. These are not pragmatic questions about how to do things but questions about being before doing.

A passion for quality in work

To facilitate the second step, we started as a joint venture between the SPES Academy and UNIZO, the Belgian Union for independent entrepreneurs a project called Inspirational Entrepreneurship. The idea was very simple: if you want to know how spiritual-based leadership works, confront yourself with a spirit-driven entrepreneur.  Ask him/her where the spiritual and ethical drive comes from and how it makes a difference in terms of strategy, human resource management, marketing, profit sharing, communication and community involvement? Every year with a group of interested entrepreneurs we visit a series of small and medium sized companies. Reports of the visits are published in booklets. (5) One of the most striking characteristics of spirit driven entrepreneurship that we discovered during these visits, was their particular passion for the quality and authenticity of their product. 

Hard working entrepreneurs are not eager to speak much about spirituality. They don’t like grand statements and do not use an explicit spiritual vocabulary. They prefer to speak about the quality and authenticity of their product. An authentic product cannot be reduced to its functional and economic utility. One of the entrepreneurs we visited, a coffee-maker, spoke about his product in a very revealing way. For him, coffee was a relational good linking farmers in the South with coffee drinkers in the North. He informed us about the different kind of beans and their ecological environment, the problems of transport and the delicate process of production. He introduced coffee as a cultural good: a ritual that begins and structures our day and helps people to talk to each other. From his passion for coffee we can learn that spiritual-based entrepreneurship is not primarily about good stakeholder management. Just as the inspiration of an artist does not depend on how (s)he relates to other people but on how (s)he creates meaning through his/her work of art, so the spirituality of an entrepreneur is mainly expressed in his/her passion for a product that creates meaning and interconnectedness.

Creating conditions for co-creative communication

The third step to practice spiritual-based leadership is the creation of good communication. In most approaches good communication is seen as a means to realize the goals of a company expressed by its shareholders or stakeholders. If we adhere to the shareholder vision of a company, we will interpret communication as an instrument to create maximum value for shareholders. In the case of a stakeholder vision good communication will be measured by its capacity to create an added value for all the stakeholders. But in both cases communication will still remain a tool for disciplining people rather than a genuine conversation.

Spiritual-based leadership opens another, non-instrumental view of communication. It defines communication as the process of creating a co-responsible and co-creative community. The reference point is no longer a set of goals and targets but a shared sense of community and commitment. If communication is too much instrumentalised in function of goals and targets, it will fail in mobilizing people and engaging employees.  Transformative and relational language has another logic than informative and instrumental language. Transformative language creates meaning and a sense of moral co-ownership while instrumental language reduces the actors to their functional use.  

Whatever their juridical statute, all persons co-creating value and investing time, money, talent or trust in a company are, ethically spoken, co-owners of a company. However, to be fully realized, the ethical claim of co-ownership needs to be completed with a formal and contractual structure of stakeholder participation. But a formal structure of participation never guarantees the inner spirit of co-creativity and co-responsibility. Empirical research indicates that despite many managerial efforts, a genuine spirit of co-ownership  is rather rare. It requires a sense of leadership based on relations of mutual trust, reciprocity and open communication.  According to Gallup's new 142-country study on the State of the Global Workplace (Gallup Report, 2013) only 13% of employees worldwide are engaged at work, 24% are actively disengaged and 63 % feel no genuine interest or commitment in their work.

The following example taken from F.D. Jensen (1996)  may illustrate the power of trust-based leadership. The example tells us the story of Oticon, a Danish company with branches worldwide that sell hearing-aids and related technologies. Until the 1990s the company was structured according to the traditional model of bureaucratic rationality: a clear hierarchical pyramid, divided into departments each of which is responsible for managing its own affairs, quantitative economic goals as standards for measuring and monitoring success, emphasis on formal procedures. In the beginning of the 1990s,  the dollar fell to half its value in Danish crowns. This meant a catastrophic decline in revenue for Oticon, since its most important market was in the United States. The company was facing a crisis. Meetings were held left and right, but the loss of control continued to rise. The Board of Directors pulled the emergency brake. The eight executive directors were dismissed and Lars Kolind, manager of a high tech firm (Radiometer Inc.) was hired as director. In response to the crisis, he developed an ambitious vision for the Oticon group: Oticon was to be restructured into an ‘anthropocentric network’ that grew to become a world leader in audiology and within five years became listed on the Danish stock market.

Kolind’s basic philosophy consisted of dismantling bureaucratic rationality and creating in its place a ‘moral free space’, a space for freedom and personal responsibility. In practice, this meant the abolition of all titles and departmental structures, of fixed working hours, of clearly defined jobs; moreover, all information apart from a few confidential details was to be made accessible to everyone. Kolind wanted a company that was structurally comparable to the human brain: chaotic, non-hierarchical and effective. Each person was able to make suggestions and proposals directly to Kolind himself. If anyone did not receive a reply within twenty-four hours he or she could consider the suggestion as having been accepted, and could count on the means for realising it. If Kolind was unavailable to receive the suggestion, one could add a surcharge for the lost time (in the form of an internal interest payment) to the project.

Not everyone could adapt to Kolind’s style, which called for a high degree of personal responsibility and creativity. Some left the company. When the group succeeded in designing a new hearing system based on digital technology, the company made a leap forward. Kolind’s style had evidently released people’s self-confidence and creativity. He described the core of his leadership in the following way: ‘The key lies in the notion of trust. No one can resist trust. The basic assumption that guides my notion of leadership is that the personnel will only take responsibility for itself and look after the common good if management is able to create an environment that promotes trust and autonomy.’ (Jensen, 1996: 26)

Conclusions

How can we foster spiritual awareness as a lever for a new period of global social and economic ‘renaissance’?   

First, we should view spirituality as a public good and not just as a private matter. People from different religions, nationalities, political parties, scientific disciplines or social classes become aware that we reached the limits of our  current system of ego-centric growth and rational management. Paradoxes in economic and social life reveal the limits and contradictions. Without a full understanding of these paradoxes, we will be unable to realize the spiritual correction that is needed.

Second, if we want to foster spirituality in public and social life, we must start with unlocking our own spiritual self as a presence of deep interconnectedness. This requires an ongoing process of reflection, self criticism, listening to our inner intuitions and learning from the wisdom of other people. Without this effort, spirituality will end up in subjectivism and escapism.

Third, we have to translate spirituality from a personal to an organizational level. This implies that an organization learns to think and act from an inner mission and value system and not only from current market incentives and ad hoc opportunities.  Spiritual-based leadership is the art of disclosing the capacity of an organization to think and act as a co-responsible and value-driven community. To-day we call this capacity of thinking and acting as a co-creative an co-responsible community the spiritual capital of an organization.  In this perspective, business spirituality can be defined as management of an organization’s spiritual capital. 

References

Bass, B. M.,1990. “From transactional to transformational leadership: Learning to share the      vision”. In: Organizational Dynamics, (Winter), pp.19-31.

Bouckaert, L. 2006. “The Ethics Management Paradox” in: Zsolnai, L. (ed): Interdisciplinary      Yearbook of Business Ethics. Peter Lang, Oxford, 2006, pp. 199-202 and pp. 215-219.

Bouckaert, L. & Zsolnai L (eds). 2007. Spirituality as a public good, Antwerp, Garant (European SPES Cahier 1).

Bouckaert, L. 2011. “Spirituality and Rationality” In: Bouckaert, L. & Zsolnai, L.(eds), The Palgrave Handbook of Spirituality and Business, Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire, pp.       18-26.

Bouckaert, L. Opdebeeck, H. and Zsolnai, L. (eds) 2008. Frugality: Rebalancing Material and Spiritual Values in Economic Life. 2008. Peter Lang, Oxford.

Bouckaert, L. 2013. “Schumacher and the Principle of Responsibility in Economics” In:      Opdebeeck H., Responsible Economics. E.F.Schumacher and his Legacy for the 21st        Century, Peter Lang, Oxford, pp.209-225.

Easterlin, R. 1974. “Does Economic Growth Improve the Human Lot? Some Empirical       Evidence.” In: Paul A. David and Melvin W. Reder (eds), Nations and Households in         Economic Growth: Essays in Honor of Moses Abramovitz, New York, Academic Press,       Inc.

Gallup Report, 2013, State of the Global Workplace: Employee Engagement Insights for   Business Leaders Worldwide, www.gallup.com/poll/116431/research-reports.aspx

Hessel Stéphane, 2011, Time for Outrage. Charles Glass Books, London. The original French title           Indignez-vous! was  published in 2010, Indigène, Montpellier , 32 pages.

Jensen, F. D. 1996. “Ethics at work”. Siena, Research Paper presented at EBEN Conference.

Lao Tzu, 1988. Tao The Ching (translated by Stephen Mitchell), Frances Lincoln, London.

Levinas, E. 1974. Totalité et Infini. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff.

Schumacher, E.F. 2004 (first edition 1977). A Guide for the Perplexed. London: Harper Perennial.

Sölle Dorothée, The Silent Cry: Mysticism and Resistance. Minneapolis, Fortress Press. 


[1] See F. Schumacher about the solution of divergent problems in his Guide for the Perplexed, chapter 10 (Schumacher ,2004).

[2] Even within a modern welfare state with a balanced system of social security, the correlation  between social happiness and social welfare remains problematic. How to explain in a well developed welfare state the rising rates of depression, stress, burn-out, suicide and loss of meaning in life?

[3] This is not a new idea. The claim of ‘spirituality first’ and the search for integral humanism as a consequence of it, were already made during the interbellum period in Europe by personalist thinkers such as Jacques Maritain and Emmanuel Mounier and expressed in the Journal Esprit (Spirit). (1) Some years before, the Indian philosopher and  poet Rabindranath Tagore made a similar claim and gave it an Indian expression in the Visva Bharati University and its claim to combine human science and spirituality. The European SPES Forum is a network that tries to keep alive this legacy of spirituality in economic and social life. Our situation today makes the claim of ‘spirituality first’ only more timely and relevant.

[4] SPES is a Belgian and international network aiming at disclosing spirituality as a lever of economic and social progress. SPES means hope but is also used as an acronym for Spirituality in Economics and Society. See www.eurospes.be & www.spesforum.be

[5] Besides the two examples given in the  paper (natural mysticism and the experience of vulnerability) we may think of deep experiences of silence, genuine conversation, prayer  or shared religious rituals as ways to disclose interconnectedness. 

Go to top
Notice: Undefined index: adv in /home/kamranmofid/public_html/templates/jsn_epic_pro/index.php on line 654
buying cialis in bulk buy priligy without prescription viagra testimonials cialis rx buy viagra oral jelly generic generic cialis pills cod pharmaprix canda yasmin pill viagra dailymed viagra sheets generic cialis 60 mg viagra rrp australia cost prendre viagra et hypertension affordable viagra is it legal to buy cialis from canada vipps online pharmacy viagra effects of 100 mg viagra viagra causing retinal bleeding viagra alternitives viagra kanada mccain avoids viagra cooper dangers of generic cialis historia del viagra find search viagra generic edinburgh viagra for the brain pill lloyds pharmacy viagra online viagra vs cialis vs levitra comparison which one is better viagra cialis or levitra viagra female buy where can i buy cheap viagra yahoo furosemide in uk red cialis viagra kullanımı keflex generic cost viagra shqip soft viagra quick delivery cialis user reviews viagra generic patent expires viagra tablet price in indian rupees natural viagra cape town prices for cialis desi viagra brand name viagra pegym preise viagra in deutschland viagra aus internet gefährlich viagra men over 50 cialis daily use cost canada online antibiotics viagra little blue pill l arginine and viagra together female viagra pill where can i buy cialis in australia with paypal jak dziala viagra na kobiety us online pharmacy selling kamagra viagra canada patent expiration date ed 0nline store sustitutos naturales de viagra oberoi new delhi viagra natural form of viagra viagra nedir ekşi sözlük use of viagra cipla viagra viagra cialis ou levitra preço viagra 2009 sales how to order viagra online in canada viagra dla kobiet kup viagra at gnc sildenafil kamagra jelly cialis vs viagra stronger viagra braucht man ein rezept 1/4 viagra how much is viagra at tesco stories viagra porn levitra cost walgreens cut cialis 20mg in half nolvadex for sale there really natural viagra independent viagra injectable viagra buy viagra london shop half dosage of viagra proscar side effects viagra will viagra make you harder buy viagra in sydney mixing viagra and cocaine potencimex is there generic viagra viagra drugs online generic viagra order viagra tablet side effects viagra patent protection expires cheap norvasc cheap viagra edinburgh find pages sites does cialis work well 500 mg amoxicillin for sale viagra and women side effects viagra otc usa generic viagra premature ejaculation viagra 50m phone number to order viagra viagra equivalent in homeopathy cialis 200 mg price sildenafil mail order viagra efectos secundarios phony viagra cipro 750mgs sale where to buy viagra condoms donde comprar viagra what's best viagra cialis comapre viagra and cialis vardenafil vs cialis viagra and tinnitus best price viagra in australia champix online kaufen generic viagra 100 mg viagra cupons viagra journalism como usar viagra generico can you buy viagra in france can i get viagra in dubai Erection Pills GNC hqdrugs pharm support group levitra viagra online kenya viagra walmart mexico where can i buy herbal viagra www canadapharmacy all side effects viagra viagra without prescription in usa modo de usar o viagra order viagra from canada can sell viagra ebay maker of viagra buy cialis nyc xenical diet pills side effects synthroid generic cost viagra aus schweiz viagra ireland hgh human growth hormone cialis preise frankreich purpose use viagra who should not take viagra homemade viagra drink cipro xr cialis suppliers canadian top pharmacy viagra online einkaufen cialis online no prescription oral jelly kamagra uk viagra for sale fast shipping the long and difficult 13-year viagra sildenafil viagra dosage dose of cialis venda de viagra e cialis how to order viagra from india is cialis bad for young men prednisone muscle growth name of viagra for women do you need a prescription in canada for viagra viagra cialis levitra canadian pharmacy venda do viagra is online viagra real buy viagra cebu posso tomar viagra atenolol where to buy misoprostol online viagra soft tabs overnight viagra aus tunesien viagra price in us cialis jelly sachet vigora red viagra type drugs viagra generic name mycoxafloppin dose low viagra cialis super kamagra generika viagra apotheke erhältlich cheap viagra pills for sale viagra for the mind drugs like viagra over the counter rambaxy viagra 100mg viagra testimonials buy cheap viagra usa viagra tratamiento eyaculacion precoz viagra no prescription needed cheap sildenafil citrate reviews viagra canada ad Where buy cialis benefits of viagra how much cost viagra in india what is a natural viagra substitute order viagra online india prednisone no persciption prescription viagra by mail herbal viagra for sale in ireland vente viagra quebec viagra tablete cena rush limbaugh viagra dominican republic research viagra cheap calais pay by paypal cialis for sale philippines viagra non prescription deal sale sexualität im alter viagra when will the patent expire on viagra lasik water pills viagra online next day buy viagra chicago viagra 100 mg yahoo does viagra make you harder than normal viagra discovered albanian where to buy cialis pills helping viagra work buying viagra affilated with pharmacy center viagra trial buy viagra sydney Canada meds viagra information about viagra for men safe to buy viagra does viagra work if your paralyzed does online viagra work viagra shots cialis kaufen holland buy authentic viagra need order viagra recommended sites buy viagra cheapest viagra with prescription viagra cialis wirkungsweise como tomar un viagra side effects mixing viagra alcohol snorting viagra dangerous viagra meloxicam interaction viagra 100mg coupon can heart patients use viagra diflucan online buy generic viagra from india costco price for cialis viagra and propranolol buy prednisone cheap on line no Rx statins or niaspan and viagra viagra pi can take cialis day after viagra does cialis go bad cheap viagra alternatives is there anything like viagra for women cheap canadian viagra how long have you used viagra where to buy viagra pills online viagra red tablet levitra es mas potente que viagra real viagra with paypal cipro viagra nexium 40 mg get a store to buy it uses for viagra for women revia online ashton brothers viagra prednisone substitute what types of viagra cialis viagra stack viagra chino natural Find viagra no prescription required generic cialis warning non prescription viagra in usa blue moon viagra acquistare viagra parafarmacia duphaston buy online anyone buy cialis online pfizer viagra impotence actress in viagra commercial 2015 viagra shipped fast furosemide buy online uk paypal viagra pills online canada cialis vancouver canada cialis alternative gnc what is a natural alternative to viagra herbal viagra ingredients can i sell viagra on ebay cytotect online without prescription mail order viagra review ziac viagra tv commercial football safest online pharmacy Viagra does viagra affect male fertility edinburgh search news find viagra soft buying viagra in new zealand nolvadex no prescription canada cheep viagra viagra gone bad clomiphene citrate pharmacy best way buy viagra online what color is the viagra pill what is viagra cialis buy cialis miami cialis pills overnight cheap viagra soft tabs low cost viagra online effects of beer and viagra heartburn buy viagra.com sildenafil vs viagra buy cialis with money order buy viagra brand muscle pain after viagra revatio viagra viagra artificial herbal viagra amsterdam amiodarone viagra interaction viagra weight loss generic levitra in uk cialis for daily use cheap viagra side effects hemorrhoids es bueno el viagra generico what are generic cialis alternatives viagra bob dole 24h drugstore viagra splitting Cialis medication viagra wiht women viagra in bangalore india cialis price whatdoes viagra do to a girl amoxil capsule 250mg black guy in cialis commercial viagra safe to use everyday patent on cialis viagra 50 mg costo buy flagyl 1000 mg ferid murati viagra desi viagra brands handla viagra online viagra and amlodipine viagra how much can you take viagra in der apotheke kaufen ohne rezept viagra q and a viagra commercial actresses black 365tabs tricare prime cover viagra first viagra commercial cialis mit paypal cialis generika rezeptfrei bestellen can viagra affect blood pressure best viagra pills prezzo cialis 10 mg farmacia pharmacokinetic of viagra viagra gives me heartburn viagra prescriptions buy viagra sweden cheap viagra next day viagra half or whole can i buy viagra in italy will viagra cause heart attack viagra 100mg fiyat viagra online generic cheap travelling plane viagra viagra on cnn advertisement viagra cena srbija viagra and cialis online herbal viagra excel how much is cialis daily female viagra cream headaches with viagra cialis migraine headache buy cialis rx viagra on line propecia generic name viagra fast works pharmacy viagra cheap how long for viagra to work how to buy viagra without seeing a doctor phosphodiesterase 5 inhibitors viagra cialis peak effect viagra company info effet du cialis prix viagra pharmacie maroc rxmedline getting viagra from canada viagra add como usar o cialis otc viagra cheap generic viagra free shipping viagra from canada cheap viagra generico tempo de duração priligy generico viagra in malaysia online sildenafil 100mg what does it do brand viagra 100mg vigra cheap why is viagra a prescription drug results from using viagra viagra another name best site to buy viagra online champix generic name buy viagra ups what shops sell viagra side effects of diazepam natural viagra ingredients viagra 100mg apotheke preis viagra china supplier when does viagra patent expire in australia el viagra inhibe la eyaculacion how to buy viagra in usa viagra kvinder medicaid paying for viagra cheap viagra toronto viagra pills for sale online ed online store reviews dangers taking viagra cheap brand name viagra viagra netherlands buying viagra australia legal insurance viagra covered buy cheap viagra uk online cheapest price for viagra walmart pharmacy prices cialis viagra condom durex release date viagra que es viagra subsitute doxycycline 100mg viagra how long do effects last bactrim for uti med express viagra how it works viagra viagra in spanish viagra welche dosierung is there such a thing as female viagra free viagra sample tomar media pastilla de cialis viagra voucher free viagra price cvs how to buy viagra online safely cialis dht dosage viagra comment demander viagra son medecin genaric viagra quiero comprar viagra cheap generic viagra overnight delivery viagra from canada prices cialis from canada clomid online free shipping reasons for viagra not working viagra victoria australia first time viagra experience herbal viagra world ordering nexium samples what can cialis be used for viagra results photos prescription free generic viagra antabuse canada pharmacy without a perscription abusing viagra amoxil junior 700 mg dosis viagra pulse rate cialis paypal uk trusted websites for buying viagra online celice viagra similar medication to viagra getting viagra in cagayan de oro should you take viagra on an empty stomach pfizer viagra online australia cialis oder viagra forum buy viagra condom canada d9 viagra does rite aid sell viagra does viagra raise libido how to make watermelon viagra buy low dose cialis plavix generic purchase viagra in usa 50 mg viagra enough canadian healthcare shop viagra available boots where to buy female viagra uk viagra and cialis trial packs pfizer viagra expiration date viagra jet presentaciones cialis commercial two bathtubs viagra online to buy viagra high blood presure cheap gabapentin (neurontin) online no prescription how buy viagra hacker sent viagra bill gates how to buy viagra without a prescription crestor generic brand canadiandrugstorein reviews venta viagra doctor simi how to get rid of viagra emails viagra results videos canadian pharmacy ams comprar viagra generico curitiba how long before sex do you take viagra viagra and testosterone gel what do generic viagra look like diovan generic name ingredient in viagra cialis ad where to buy finasteride online where can i buy furosemide where can i buy metronidazole 500mg without a prescription get free viagra samples viagra shot ingredients cach dung thuoc viagra buy original cialis online overnight pharmacy viagra viagra scientist viagra india online cilias taken with viagra viagra and vision problems lasix impotence nz comprar viagra milano kamagra singapore no prescription azithromycin canadian viagra without presciption viagra augenschmerzen find viagra edinburgh pages search viagra samples free by mail kam fast kamagra viagra problems where to buy cialis in bangalore donde comprar viagra cancun reputable generic viagra cheap generic viagra from canada viagra kick in time buy generic viagra super active kann man usa viagra kaufen viagra and nitrates homoeopathic viagra viagra at 30 years old get viagra line yellow viagra pills there generic viagra cialis buy atarax no rx fed ex kelly king viagra daily cialis dose viagra phentermine buy viagra through paypal product team cialis case study young men taking viagra verified viagra sites can weman take viagra can you buy viagra in hong kong viagra online günstig viagra in dubai kaufen viagra ed photo eriacta vs viagra buy online viagra copay card 100 mg viagra reviews levitra online kaufen paypal birth control and viagra viagra drug manufacturer Buy cialis next day delivery buy viagra without a rx thug viagra best canadian pharmacy to buy from effects of viagra and cialis generic cialis 20mg best buy mexico over the counter viagra substitute gnc cua hang ban thuoc viagra can you buy viagra on amazon is viagra illegal in uae viagra is awesome sildenafil injection instructions cheapest generic viagra online prednisone online pharmacy no prescription cialis and alcohol safe viagra price at cvs the miller firm winning viagra limitations viagra cialis australia k b viagra free generic viagra buy cheap online prescription viagra viagra 50 oder 100 mg cheap viagra soft tabs overnight ship flagyl pfizer viagra tablet price levitra 20mg price viagra trial size drugs on line viagara male enhancers legitimate suppliers of viagra australia household substitute viagra buy herbal viagra online acai brazilian viagra cialis viagra comparatif does viagra last longer chao sheng long company viagra what else is viagra used for viagra prescription much siac viagra buy viagra online canada no prescription how much is viagra in philippines cheap viagra canadian pharmacies taking two viagra at once viagra after cataract surgery buy viagra southampton viagra falls new orleans can you buy viagra over the internet viagra coupons walgreens can i buy viagra in germany viagra for young adults cialis otc 2016 make your own viagra kamagra super diflucan fluconazole over the counter using cialis for performance anxiety viagra precio walmart viagra vs calais kamagra viagra te koop viagra women products viagra nose bleed is cialis the same as viagra lisinopril without prescriptions fake viagra news over the counter viagra alternatives can women take viagra nausea after viagra el viagra ayuda la eyaculacion precoz big pump viagra viagra pharmacy2u comprar viagra pela internet cheap viagra canada viagra commercial complaints kamagra store canadian pharmacy cialis generic do i need prescription to purchase viagra canadian viagra pills viagra england ohne rezept taking two cialis at once mexican viagra prices order viagra cheap viagra for recreational use nascar viagra driver watermelon better than viagra viagra cum peut on acheter du viagra en france sans ordonnance tub ceev xwm viagra best site to order viagra online lowest price genuine viagra illegal purchase viagra online where can i buy viagra in san francisco can you inject viagra lowcostviagra free viagra samples online does viagra work when drinking kind sailboat viagra commercial viagra sous prescription viagra cailis non prescription cialis alternative viagra in uk online does viagra prevent premature ejaculation diamox without a prescription viagra quick tabs viagra availability in france levitra diabetes viagra causes blue vision female pink viagra 100mg pills buy viagra manchester coke and viagra name canadian pharmacy ed pills what do i tell my doctor to get viagra helleva viagra comparação viagra good for health mixing adderall and cialis buy cialis online next day delivery viagra kamagra kopen compare prices for viagra generic no prescription viagra cialis free voucher free herbal viagra samples viagrabestbuy.com complaints where to buy viagra in ethiopia viagra find online search free buy cytotec uk seroquel buy europe how to order cialis online safely comprar viagra generico farmacia anyone ever buy viagra online viagra liquid korean viagra viagra cheap india pharmacy sub for viagra over the counter alternative for viagra why doesn't viagra work for me cialis order online costco pharmacy prices viagra viagra farmacia ahumada how many pills of viagra should i take rush arrested with viagra stop spam viagra email que es mejor viagra o kamagra viagra use after prostatectomy best price viagra 25mg what kind of doctor can prescribe viagra reputable online pharmacy generic viagra viagra stress balls premature ejaculation viagra treatment buy vegetal vigra exceed viagra and cialis maxman viagra eye pressure bystolic viagra Cialis Secure Canadian Pharmacy Net Secure Canadian Pharmacy viagra online canadian pharmacy reviews generic viagra amazon universal rx viagra chest tightness viagra generico sildenafil viagra tempi assunzione failure with viagra buy viagra new york viagra cock ring buy levitra online from usa viagra generic online genericviagra viagra online kaufen paypal generic viagra which is best open label viagra study levitra montr?Èal como usar levitra tamoxifen 20 mg mail order viargra aneurysm viagra is viagra covered by medicare cialis 5 mg opinion viagra stories reddit best dose for cialis viagra maximum dose viagra dose for pah viagra online cheap uk Buy Permethrin 5 Dermal Cream cialis dosage wiki what is viagra used for old man viagra joke viagra switch plate cialis 60 mg viagra pill for the brain how to take viagra pills viagra in use videos blue viagra pills benefits viagra men Discount cialis without prescription propecia where to buy viagra soft tabs uk buy lloyds chemist online viagra viagra temporary blindness canadapills flomax without Rx cialis actress commercial can i buy viagra over the counter at walgreens viagra australia buy will viagra work for premature ejaculation viagra 0nline where can i buy cialis in bangkok 130 mg viagra viagra popular culture Buy viagra internet cheap cialis melbourne generic viagra online fast delivery viagra generique usa cheapest viagra pills viagra ne kosove zofran odt 4 mg often can take viagra cialis once a day 5mg alternatives to viagra over the counter how to order generic viagra where to buy cialis in sukhumvit prednisone inhaler kamagra a viagra opinie use of viagra in porn industry taking viagra first time wirkt viagra bei frauen precios viagra y similares cialis en ligne cialis reviews forum Order Metronidazole without Prescription viagra market release date levitra tablets uk viagra use and side effects effets du viagra sur les hommes have fun viagra proscar generic vs brand cheap viagra from india achat vrai cialis viva viagra wav viagra sildenafil online where to buy cialis in costa rica average age of viagra users buy viagra safely online best place to buy propecia online canada charlie sheen viagra scary movie buy viagra from pfizer cialis online reviews acyclovir ointment generic cialis kaufen preis what happens if you take 200mg of viagra cialis cash price viagra urethritis how long should you wait after taking viagra men who take viagra cialis dosage 40 mg where to buy viagra in kitchener andy griffith movie viagra viagra wirkung bei frauen aldara creme sans ordonnance nolvadex mg per day epharmacy viagra super active 100mg is viagra addictive cialis buying canada que contiene el viagra para mujeres best place to buy generic viagra online reviews canadian viagra prices cialis online kaufen viagra buy online generic viagra technology is viagra available in japan viagra 666 levitra reviews side effects slogan de viagra how long viagra stays in blood viagra tablets names viagra cheapest price cialis blutdrucksenkend viagra drugs canada discount price viagra can normal man take viagra find search 76k cialis viagra pages buying antabuse online female cialis viagra receptfritt cialis and heart attacks man health radio commercial viagra viagra and minoxidil viagra order by phone discount brand viagra viagra online bangladesh viagra cheap online rx cialis reaction time natural herbal viagra online pfizer viagra viagra torrinomedica onion leaves viagra where to buy cialis online can i take cravit tab 500 after it has expired? cheapest way to buy cialis viagra patent end date irish viagra how long before sex to take cialis viagra pharmacy nhs exemption viagra Cialis in usa viagra kamagra cialis when do i take viagra when does viagra patent run out viagra ethiopia secure viagra sites can you buy viagra thailand hat jemand erfahrung mit viagra viagra y alcohol buy viagra west yorkshire viagra bei frauen wirkung viagra cialis kamagra generic viagra best online pharmacy what happens if you take viagra without ed metoprolol viagra drug interactions buying viagra chemist uk how long does it take till viagra works viagra generico españa contrareembolso medistar cialis russia viagra robbery buying viagra high street where to buy viagra perth cialis versus levitra versus viagra search female equivalent viagra effets secondaires viagra does viagra give you a hard on generic viagra quick shipping buy viagra mexico prednisone tapering schedule cost comparison viagra and cialis online prednisone viagra ad good morning canadian pharmacy vcl plant-based viagra vendo viagra italia lifespan viagra pill cheapest viagra generic substitute buy viagra online from uk cheap no prescription zithromax sildenafil efectos secundarios en mujeres consumo viagra nel mondo buy cialis in turkey viagra femenino venta libre argentina viagra oil for men rxmeds hub order cialis online viagra for bodybuilding viagra blood concentration paxil yan etkileri cinsellik glucophage tablet 250 mg cytotec overnight shipping effect of viagra on female viagra at walgreens buy viagra in algodones taking cialis daily TORONTO VIAGRA ONLIne best place to get viagra viagra versus cialis versus levitra anafranil 10 generic from canada pharmacy sign someone up viagra spam can i buy viagra over the counter in ireland levitra women plaintiffs lawsuit on viagra 2010 what's best levitra viagra or cialis bumgenius trial pack best website to buy viagra online levitra for bph where can i buy viagra over the counter in singapore cialis online canadian pharmacy buy viagra with dapoxetine online viagra uso prolungato suzuki grand viagra cheap cialis from usa kamagra fedex diflucan generic name taking viagra and beta blockers buy cialis cyprus viagra prolonged use chew viagra medstoreline universalrxpharmacy buy viagra in kuwait is generic viagra legal in uk natural levitra trial viagra is mail order viagra safe viagra se vende bajo receta half viagra pill work can buy viagra cuba is viagra otc in canada using cialis and viagra at the same time 100mg viagra for sale buy online cialis no prescription viagra for women south africa viagra for the brain good morning america will viagra show up on a test provigil viagra for the brain viagra coupon walgreens viagra in chinese el viagra y sus contraindicaciones is viagra cheaper in mexico free cialis online viagra age 20 viagra safe conception cialis ventajas buy cheap viagra mexico viagra no prior prescription theodore schenk counterfeit viagra how to use viagra for men viagra walgreens price viagra how long to work l arginine vs viagra viagra melanoma study how much is viagra at walgreens combining viagra and cialis buy viagra online from canadian pharmacy viagra pinus size difference testimonials viagra peyronie's side effects viagra after radiation best deals on genaric viagra viagra work for women where can i buy viagra in canberra levitra buy online usa reasons for taking viagra viagra dr fox alternative medicine for viagra viagra pills use death by viagra cartoon cost for viagra at costco buy viagra over the counter in new york viagra italien rezeptfrei long you stay hard viagra cialis dosering Discount viagra without prescription viagra euro cialis online england cialis preise niederlande viagra ed interazioni european chemists cart purchase prednisone online without prescription viagra side effect interaction adverse viagra reaction kann man viagra ohne rezept apotheke kaufen viagra sildenafil price viagra für die frau wirkung psych viagra falls dollhouse music what effect does viagra have on women viagra two nights row pfizer viagra free samples Cialis com viagra before surgery herbal viagra reviews viagra buy japan ed pills cialis side effects viagra satış fiyatları generic viagra legitimate excessive dose viagra viagra history herb viagra review viagra on line canada What does viagra cost? buy viagra in abu dhabi too much cialis brand name cialis for sale online viagra in cream edinburgh uk viagra tid cfm moo buying viagra in korea CILAS where to buy viagra in myanmar viagra online yahoo answers viagra generic name real viagra united states effexor xr dosage viagra cost ontario viagra 50 fiyat comprar viagra en uruguay viagra urethral free samples viagra viagra online xlpharmacy cheap viagra no prescription canada viagra kamagra forum cialis 10mg tadalafil viagra tablets in vizag can internet viagra lose effectiveness over time viagra online in the usa viagra vietnam where to buy mail order viagra india viagra sale las vegas bestcanadianpills where viagra is available in india viagra just fun generic viagra online ireland levitra online pagamento alla consegna viagra super p-force get prednisone online is it illegal to import viagra viagra potency effect does viagra have blood pressure proscar order viagra light switch covers canadian rx viagra acheter viagra en france pas cher whats cialis do prednisone in children generic viagra cialis levitra cheap zyvox generic launch girl on viagra cialis coupon free trial buy viagra bangladesh buy cialis generic online cheap cipro brand name cialis 20 mg para que sirve free samples viagra does alcohol affect use viagra viagra co tac dung nhu nao buy viagra soft online cipro dosage for gallbladder infection turkish viagra review buy kamagra using paypal uk viagra coupon.com do need prescription buy viagra us do men like viagra online apotheke viagra 100mg soft viagra directions pros and cons of viagra buy real viagra online canada quebra patente remedio viagra can you multipule erections with viagra need a prescription for viagra buy viagra jelly online top canadian pharmacy net best place to buy generic viagra online viagra in islamabad order viagra super active+ tesco store sells viagra CanadianHealth zithromax buy online usa produit similaire au viagra levitra online pharmacy viagra feminin sans ordonnance what is the best dosage for cialis cialis uk prices viagra meme desi viagra medicine name tesco viagra prescription eel viagra viagra natural how long viagra viagra vs cialis which is better viagra online melbourne australia Benicar Hct 40 25 Coupons dj viagra viagra made india safe where to buy generic z pack viagra 25 mg sildenafil citrate viagra methylprednisolone is levitra better than viagra and cialis online viagra pills legal viagra online buy cheap viagra online viagra c official deep coitus viagra photo galleries how cheap is viagra cialis pill photo online pharmacy ireland viagra which miligram dosage of cialis do i need viagra dosage chart viagra side effects memory loss antabuse viagra psychological effects arimidex buy cheapest viagra alternative viagra vancouver bc cialis advertising viagra and blood pressure medication rx viagra ru viagra p5 inhibitor canadianmeds online viagra generic overnight delivery where to buy generic viagra online in canada donde comprar cialis en miami safe online pharmacy cialis risks using viagra order levitra canada efectos de la viagra en jovenes eyesight viagra viagra just men cialis mg who sells the best generic viagra viagra the facts viagra generic online viagra vs cialis price l arginine vs viagra active ingredient in viagra natural genuine viagra box order viagra paypal buy cheap viagra tablets airport security viagra women using viagra cuales son los componentes del viagra prednisone online no script viagra in tijuana the viagra pill viagra small doses cheap viagra with free shipping viagra and nasal congestion azithromycin no prescription viagra combination therapy pills just like viagra female viagra stories cialis kontraindikacije buy viagra with dapoxetine buy cialis online south africa is levitra cheaper than viagra where is the best place to order viagra online canadian viagra sales erectile dysfunction viagra does not work viagra ed equivalenti viagra for men free samples viagra tabs online viagra side effects incidence dove comprare cialis generico sicuro viagra safe all men premarin buy compare viagra and kamagra viagra china viagra generic patent expiration requip hcl 1 mg buy cialis now viagra cheapest price generic brand viagra from usa are there any over the counter pills like viagra buy levaquin online viagra bodybuilding when should cialis be taken? cialis and poppers does viagra really expire pictures of viagra results illegal take viagra thailand viagra pills for sale l arginina viagra luvox cr generic sildenafil citrate discount viagra cialis kidney is generic viagra availabe in canada viagra prescription price sildenafil venta mexico viagra cost walgreens viagra cost 2011 tomar viagra la primera vez cheap viagra generic uk cialis stopped working phizer viagra copd research gibt wenn glühwürmchen viagra frisst levitra trial offer supplements that work like viagra viagra without prescription cialis generic viagra side effects viagra addictive cialis and food viagra grapefruit juice viagra pricing comparison cialis and headaches side effects file viewtopic t 144 viagra viagra drug study viagra health canada substitute for viagra viagra patent up buy generic viagra with paypal purchase viagra viagra alternative malaysia viagra phuket pharmacy cheapest viagra canada viagra generic price viagra women boehringer ingelheim much does viagra cost uk cialis or levitra ou viagra cvs viagra alternative what car is in the viagra commercial viagra online eu how long for viagra to peak kamagra samples Buy Clindamycin Phosphate Topical Gel 1 viagra super force france viagra in budapest viagra alternative preise cialis rezeptfrei discounts for cialis dosis viagra recomendada order levitra online canada viagra patent buy cialis mumbai Storage Life of Cialis viagra apotheken test can women take levitra most porn stars use viagra order viagra online dubai montelukast sod 10 mg tablet order viagra canada online turn viagra drink cheap viagra for sale uk vi va viagra herb viagra generic viagra super force buy viagra online canadian pharmacy cialis cost viagra 50 mg first time cialis natural cost of cialis walmart viagra medical deduction viagra covered under medicare where can i buy viagra over the counter in london viagra red pills is it illegal to buy viagra online in canada viagra effects jack3d viagra lady viagra best place to buy viagra online reviews viagra cialis levitra karşılaştırma viagra naturale generic alternative to cialis gold max viagra reviews viagra mit rezept günstig viagra legal in holland kaufen videsh sewa home viagra has anyone ever taken generic cialis buy viagra online in cyprus acheter du viagra aux usa over the counter viagra substitute cvs cheapest cialis cialis out of date how do i get viagra from my gp viagra melanoma link viagra a vendre canada which is better cialis or viagra free viagra cialis does singulair work like viagra viagra over the counter philippines viagra mails hotmail over the counter products like viagra womens cialis reviews viagra soft and alcohol como comprar viagra no rio de janeiro viagra uses how to check viagra authenticity kamagra oral jelly gel 100 mg buy viagra by the pill 866 503 4818 online pharmacy isentress viagra viagra treatment for pe indian viagra fungus jodi west viagra cupon for viagra viagra related medications casodex generic name order doxycycline how much is viagra in hong kong healthy man viagra respiratory Suppliers of Amoxicillin UK condom with viagra gel how many times can you ejaculate with viagra vand viagra pfizer bucuresti viagra on plants viagra symptoms viagra cost in spain esomeprazole magnesium buy online over the counter santo domingo viagra generic viagra from canada pharmacy lovegra what happens when a lady takes viagra viagra 100 mg quanto dura order viagra overnight delivery on line drugs with pay pal can i buy cialis over the counter uk generic viagra prescription online femme prend viagra keyword order viagra viagra users testimonials viagra commercial gas station viagra with high blood pressure canadian rx viagra where to purchase cialis online health worldbiz buy seroquel rxmeds hub order brand cialis online does viagra improve ed over time buy viagra from india equal to viagra herb better than viagra viagra dissolve in water viagra mcgrath viagra werkingsduur jual viagra di surabaya how long till levitra works viagra and ecstacy and older men caffeine pills white cross what would happen if a girl takes viagra prednisone forum what does viagra do order viagra visit your doctor online generic viagra when safe viagra from india viagra 100 mg fiyatları viagra coupons cvs what is viagra made from viagra how long to take effect 50 mg viagra doesn't work Etoricoxib para comprar viagra precisa receita where can we buy viagra in philippines viagra price greece viagra pulmonary heart tim hieu thuoc viagra viagra online belgium xanax interaction with viagra hq drugs online small order cialis steroids and viagra dangers can we take viagra with alcohol buy cheap levitra uk best substitute to viagra buy online viagra review best time to take viagra priligy generico funziona viagra cream for woman viagra spam my email viagra online to australia how safe is viagra online zovirax buy online overnight herbal viagra reviews what happens if you snort viagra where to buy viagra online safely cialis side effects back pain pharmacy checker viagra viagra falls south bend get viagra spam ace inhibitors viagra giving pandas viagra is viagra safe with depresion medication does generic cialis really work viagra 100mg and alcohol how much cialis do you take effects of cialis puchase prednisone viagra max dose liquid viagra review percent men using viagra daily cialis uk viagra street use viagra anatomy viagra facial viagra causas y consecuencias viagra not good you viagra and poppers side effects viagra online canada overnight viagra and poppers cost cialis buy viagra craigslist viagra for sale in boots natural viagra canada viagra cost bangkok cheap brand cialis online prednisone z pack viagra prescription drug australia el viagra se compra bajo receta the effects of viagra levitra cialis viagra kamagra generic viagra soft flavored 100 generic pills shop blue eyesight viagra cialis te koop in nederland does viagra work on women too calcium channel blockers and viagra pepcid viagra canadianpharmacymeds viagra low blood pressure viagra stomach acid forums buy viagra online order prednisone without perscription in us can buy viagra korea cialis anafranil cialis free trial voucher medrol prednisone buy generic advair diskus online lily otway buy cheap cialis usa visa cheap levitra 10mg other health benefits of viagra niagara falls pharmacy cialis cost of viagra online works better levitra viagra viagra found by accident synthroid mg or mcg buy online viagra in pakistan cheap cialis canadian pharmacy pfizer viagra ebay generique levitra 20 utilisation du viagra chez la femme kamagra gel for women viagra muadilleri viagra in delhi search viagra free sites find generic cialis indian norvasc without a perscription viagra daily mixing ambien viagra buying antabuse when is viagra off patent in uk viagra online at viagra overnight shipping republican amendment viagra paxil 10 mg buy cialis get free viagra buy viagra london same day cialis brand name online stories of viagra discounted cialis negative effects viagra generic cialis 60 mg cheapest place to buy viagra uk will viagra fail drug test facts on viagra doctor viagra sample online viagra non prescription farmacias similares zoloft with viagra women viagra pregnancy cialis 5mg online should viagra be taken on an empty stomach xanax and cialis interactions take viagra daily como se toma el viagra yahoo where can i get viagra today cost of viagra with medicare flushed face viagra viagra cz is it illegal to buy viagra on the streets cialis vs. viagra purchase viagra online buy viagra california can you buy viagra over the counter in germany cheap viagra samples russian man dies after guzzeling viagra female viagra review 2013 buy viagra online in uk no prescription viagra en doctor simi buy zithromax over the counter viagra risks recreational use there any natural alternatives viagra viagra usa online pharmacy rx generic viagra purchase viagra by phone simon campbell viagra what is the best viagra eladó viagra cialis kamagra discrete cialis branded viagra best uk prices viagra on female buy viagra in dubai viagra new price canada viagra new delhi viagra 70 canadian cialis online pharmacy cheapest viagra substitute sildenafil viagra generic online uk generic viagra directions brand viagra pharmacy viagra now eu index welt online viagra efecto cialis en mujeres how long does a viagra last for comprar viagra sevilla does viagra help you last longer viagra suppositories buy viagra from gp viagra generic at walmart viagra pfizer revenue viagra information from drugs.com viagra increase stamina viagra online argentina tiger viagra joke buy viagra gauteng generic or viagra cialis travelling abroad with viagra can you really buy cialis online viagra gnc 15 mg cialis uso del viagra en adultos viagra from mexico viagra didnt work email virus for viagra buy azithromycin 1gm pak powder online viagra los angeles taking viagra after cialis viagra food interactions viagra poland emphysema viagra viagra for libido find buy cheap viagra search generic cialis pulmonary hypertension canadien pharmacy prednisone sample pack viagra cialis side effects of cialis viagra levitra viagra pages edinburgh boring search girl viagra main ingredient super herbal viagra free viagra trial viagra info uk effets secondaires cialis 5mg metformin no prescription pfizer viagra patent viagra peligroso para hipertensos viagra recreational viagra canadian pharmacy reviews goodrx viagra viagra head office cialis singapore clinic viagra online scams viagra through customs order discount cialis online reacciones secundarias del viagra viagra not working how old to take viagra valacyclovir buy no prescription viagra equivalent medicine in india find search viagra free computer edinburgh how to use chinese viagra watermelon and viagra anti alcohol pill sale viagra on women flomax non perscription pharmacy purchase viagra canada viagra in india online purchase viagra buy pharmacy iframe viagra hardness scale when will cialis be available over the counter viagra efectos negativos walgreens - viagra que es el viagra profesional topcadianpharmacyonline natural viagra pill isnt viagra working me price of daily use cialis viagra lowest price what drugs work like viagra mail order viagra uk ladies viagra images replace viagra herbal viagra hong kong cost of cialis without insurance what does viagra do cheap canadian valtrex extenze good viagra age limits on viagra viagra spam outlook herbal substitute for viagra how to use cialis for best results price of viagra in turkey free viagra samples without purchase viagra super kamagra fox news viagra women prozac use of viagra where can i buy viagra safely opposite reaction to viagra cialis side effects heartburn printable cialis coupon comprar viagra original online viagra pregnancy generic cialis without rx generic viagra cheapest uk unicure remedies pvt ltd viagra deaths viagra and equivalent viagra pic viagra pill cutter viagra and orgasm viagra online us news cialis for bph buy on line without prescription viagra for men over the counter que es el viagra soft gebruik van viagra pil es bueno tomar viagra jello viagra download viagra cheapest online sellers dosage cialis prozac viagra priligy buy online europe can i buy viagra at walgreens ed trial pack online shipped to canada herbal viagra for men content d panfilov md activities memberships facts about viagra cialis sin receta en chile marcas de genericos de viagra cialis time peak effect buy viagra in tijuana como conseguir viagra en las palmas money online order save viagra kırmızı kanguru viagra viagra soft tabs online treating viagra indigestion viagra not working generic cialis kopen viagra side effects buy viagra online from usa ou acheter viagra au canada nơi mua viagra viagra frauen ohne rezept generic cialis facts viagra and losartan levitra problems bu viagra with a dicover card ben stiller viagra brand name viagra prices viagra pictures before and after canada rx seroquel sexpillscenter enhance viagra metformin online canada viagra femenina mexico how can i buy viagra online viagra for sale in jakarta bactrim without pres buy advair online viagra and high blood pressure medication viagra for anxiety buy cheap viagra generic online buy viagra india order viagra online pharmacy taking viagra twice a day cialis no prescription generic safe viagra viagra cheap shipping viagra split pill cialis skin rash viagra serial number existe viagra para mujeres funciona france viagra 2 free viagra cialis vs viagra price viagra 100 mg half life flagyl purchase online for humans daily dose cialis generico viagra funciona viagra rezept beim arzt how to take cialis 20mg getting viagra online canada buy cialis cheap prices fast delivery what effect does viagra have on women viagra online br average cost of cialis 5mg emanuelle viagra what is retail cost of cialis viagra online eczane viagra tablets usa guy overdose viagra where to order viagra online forum is there a female version of viagra what mg viagra should i take viagra sites dapoxetine for sale teva generic viagra generic viagra online pharmacy canada online pharmacy xenical order viagra online from india viagra for women for sale ireland prescription pad viagra hard ejaculate que es el viagra y como funciona is kamagra good how much generic viagra should i take can i take 2 5mg cialis viagra on cnn advertisement viagra y fertilidad femenina medical info on viagra is it safe to buy viagra in bali cialis online miglior prezzo sideeffects of viagra is it legal to buy viagra online in canada clomid online generic viagra best viagra cialis levitra cost comparison viagra kills people history of viagra sales pfizer viagra online pharmacy requip goodrx comprar viagra online seguro como se puede tomar viagra power bull 100 meddig hat viagra non prescription viagra walgreens effect of women taking viagra viagra 25 ml onde comprar viagra no rio de janeiro say get prescribed viagra levitra vs cialis vs viagra levitra bester preis types of viagra in india sildenafil y vision borrosa viagra stories real people's experiences cheap viagra in united states has anyone ordered viagra online aftermarket viagra cialis com coupon new york cialis is it legal to buy prednisone online how do you take cialis lloyds pharmacy viagra over the counter gia ban cua thuoc viagra cialis with weed cialis vs viagra dosage losartan viagra side effects jelly kamagra generic viagra vs brand viagra viagra online bestellen erfahrungen best way to order viagra online viagra available malaysia pills cialis viagra joke 36 hour cialis to buy usa edinburgh pages find search viagra kamagra where to buy female viagra for men what happens when you take too much viagra if you take viagra under 18 cialis and viagra together viagra in europe when to take viagra can you become addicted to viagra best place to buy viagra online 2013 hamster viagra jokes maxalt 5 mg quality generic viagra viagra 100 mg best price viagra efecte negative robber fed only viagra viagra no prescription in usa buy viagra in costa rica scam indian viagra dubai different types of viagra pills viagra best price australia viagra military cvs viagra coupon Viagra visa tking viagra walgreen sildenafil generic herbal viagra nz buy generic viagra online free shipping synthroid no prescription canada efectos secundarios viagra en mujeres viagra generic overnight delivery features and benefits of viagra viagra from health store priligy e viagra order viagra online usa viagra ship canada viagra free pills viagra online canada or usa effectiveness cialis versus viagra viagra campaign spray viagra for women viagra insomnia side effects of taking canadian viagra safe place to buy viagra online forum canadadrugpharmacy viagra professional online natures viagra comments on viagra from users aquarium azithromycin viagra canada buy online cheap cialis no prescription viagra night vision viagra generic in uk canadian online pharmacies viagra can you buy viagra over the counter in northern ireland viagra mechanism viagra for hypertension where to buy viagra in san jose viagra cause rosacea viagra online booking order cialis online ottawa viagra sin receta en chile viagra military viagra cause liver damage viagra für windows nexium canada price viagra 50 mg vs 100 mg wal mart pharmacy viagra price pradaxa and cialis medical side affects of viagra original viagra price in india existe el viagra para mujeres buy viagra france que es mejor viagra o m force free sites results computer viagra pfizer viagra commercial viagra over the counter toronto girl who took viagra is there an over the counter form of viagra viagra pills online viva viagra tv commercial is there a pharmacy in cancun airport buy cialis daily online cheapest brand viagra online viagra discovery lawsuits of blindness viagra online bestellen nederland prevacid where to purchase viagra supplement levitra sale online california doctors online for cialis prescription genericviagraonlineuk dapoxetine buy uk how easy is it to get viagra from doctor viapro vs viagra viagra generico de la india viagra boner viagra cialis i levitra levitra alcohol side effects viagra legal holland kaufen 365 pills mobi catalog viagra viagra male fertility where to buy prednisone no prescription viagra online uk boots viagra pricing cvs cheap viagra uk next day do chemists sell viagra peyronie y viagra super viagra beads viagra in holland kaufen cialis sample coupon viagra ad actress football jersey man uses viagra viagra pelvic examination pills work like viagra viagra edinburgh search find pages purchase viagra in mexico gaddafi issues viagra how do i get viagra in india viagra temperature storage viagra canada cost inderal buy no prescription order viagra pills online viagra whiskey average price of viagra in canada viagra pfizer generico efectos secundarios viagra herbal how much for viagra prescription uk clinic viagra typical viagra results sudafed viagra interaction best place to purchase generic viagra generic viagra without prescription fastest viagra delivery viagra and marijuana pfizer viagra directions viagra femenino yes buy viagra sildenafil buy cialis generic online generic viagra potency viagra commercial 2013 printing order viagra online overnight delivery best website for generic cialis buy viagra in mexico viagra levitra comprar online medications viagra gold viagra 3000mg zovirax online cheap viagra online nz why don't lawyers take viagra purchase levitra viagra mail order Buy Cialis Online Now women who take viagra silagra or viagra buy viagra online legit buy cheap viagra canada viagra testimonials online viagra order cost of cialis in new zealand affects of viagra homopathic viagra heartburn with viagra viagra gel thailand buy viagra generic natural power herbal viagra generic cialis in bangkok cialis generic date que efectos produce el viagra viagra for brain provigil funny viagra is there 1000mg azithromycin in capsules that I csn purchade prednisone on line no prescription Master Card viagra in afghanistan buy cialis online overnight shipping buy salbutamol tablets online viagra and erection buy viagra lloyds pharmacy viagra en ligne canada generic viagra without presciption legal viagra 50 or 100 buy levitra online without prescription Cialis use buy viagra online edmonton buy nizoral buy levitra with dapoxetine sildenafil zentiva 100mg filmtabletten low cost viagra online viagra prescription msud zyvox generic 2015 girl viagra can women use levitra where to buy viagra buy viagra online from india gnc store viagra como comprar viagra por internet en argentina buy cheap cialis discount online distribution channel of viagra viagra 4 u ad agency for viva viagra viagra brand manager levitra samples viagra plus 400 mg nombre del viagra femenino review of generic viagra cheap genuine viagra uk viagra sin tener problemas ereccion mix cialis and viagra cialis y red bull generic viagra discussion viagra para mujeres en uruguay buy viagra online chennai is viagra banned in india cialis super force viagra amsterdam buy non prescription viagra canadian pharmacy kann viagra kaufen schweiz dose de viagra zetra viagra natural opiniones dapoxetine hong kong viagra andcialis pills like viagra at walmart counterfeit cialis viagra raise or lower blood pressure viagra super force uk viagra and increased heart rate getting viagra germany www.viagra coupon viagra eyesight levitra street value experience of using viagra viagra for women testostrone viagra and metoprotol cheap cialis and viagra quais os generico do viagra