Share

 First written on 11 April 2011

Updated on 9 November 2015

Photo: neweconomics.org

Small is Beautiful:
The Wisdom of E.F. Schumacher

16 August 1911-4 September 1977

"Perhaps we cannot raise the winds. But each of us can put up the sail, so that when the wind comes we can catch it."

- E. F. Schumacher,Small Is Beautiful: a study of economics as if people mattered

Kamran Mofid- (Written in appreciation of E.F. Schumacher and in celebration of his centenary) 

Introduction

It is 38 years since the publication of a slim volume of articles and essays titled Small is Beautiful: Economics as if people mattered.  The year 1973, as Martin Hodgson writing in the Guardian has noted, was a timely one for radical environmental thinking. The first UN conference on sustainable development had been held the previous year, and soon after, within months of each other, Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth and the UK Green party were founded.

Small is Beautiful rapidly became a bestseller and the ideas that Schumacher popularised helped shape modern environmentalism, development theory and the global justice movement.

Equal parts economic analysis, spiritual tract and radical manifesto, the book reflected the contradictory nature of its author - a patrician academic who was also passionately interested in Eastern philosophy. What bound his work was a central belief that modern society had lost touch with basic human needs and values - and in doing so had failed both the planet and its people.

In the name of profit and technological progress, Schumacher argued, modern economic policies had created rampant inefficiency, environmental degradation and dehumanising labour conditions. "Ever bigger machines, entailing ever bigger concentrations of economic power and exerting ever greater violence against the environment, do not represent progress: they are a denial of wisdom. Wisdom demands a new orientation of science and technology towards the organic, the gentle, the non-violent, the elegant and beautiful," he wrote.

The remedy he proposed - a holistic approach to human society, which stressed small scale, localised solutions - flew in the face of economic orthodoxies of the time: "I have no doubt that it is possible to give a new direction to technological development, a direction that shall lead it back to the real needs of man, and that also means: to the actual size of man. Man is small, and, therefore, small is beautiful."

Schumacher’s Small is Beautiful is an appeal to the deep instinctive understanding of the common good that all people share. It is an appeal to our essential humanity. It deals with some of the most pressing concerns of people the world over, concerns which every generation must consider and answer. It is written in the hope of inspiring idealism and the desire to give the practical help the world so greatly needs. The book encourages us to reflect on and to understand things we all seem to have forgotten: What is Education? What is Knowledge? What is Wisdom? What is the source of true happiness and well-being? What is the good life? What is the purpose of economic life? What does it mean to be a human being living on a spaceship with finite resources? What paths can be recommended to shift the current destructive global political-economic order from one of unrestrained economic growth, profit maximisation and cost minimisation, to one that embraces material wealth creation, yet also preserves and enhances social and ecological well-being and increases human happiness and contentment?

I discovered Schumacher and “Small is Beautiful” in 1979. To be precise: on August 11, 1979. I had written the date I purchased the book on the first page. At that time I was an undergraduate studying economics at the University of Windsor, Ontario, Canada.

When I saw the book in the window of a second-hand book shop, I was, very much intrigued by the title and also the sub-title Economics as if people mattered which caught my imagination. Thus, I bought the book and began to read it immediately. I could not put it down and finished it in a few days.

For sure I didn't understand every word, indeed I suspect I was lost at times, but it thrilled me. Here was a new way of looking at many questions in my head about economics and the economy, an approach that I felt in my enthusiasm was so absolutely right that it couldn't possibly be opposed.   I was instantly converted to a new way of looking at my personal life as well as the socio-political and economic concepts.  I suspect I became a `small is beautiful' man!

Schumacher’s thoughts have never left me.  Yes, I moved on, put the book to one side and no doubt compromised.  Recently however, I've gone back to it.  I have realised that its insights are more relevant than ever.  I know again, as I did 32 years ago, that Fritz Schumacher was absolutely right and I hope that, in a modest way, we are being worthy of his legacy (See more below- Epilogue: E.F. Schumacher and I).

At present the wisdom of E. F. Schumacher seems more relevant than ever. As Walter G. Moss in an excellent article has observed, Schumacher’s wisdom is best displayed in his writings and talks of the 1970s. He was always a seeker after truth, an important quality that most wise people share. One wisdom scholar noted by Moss has written:

“Wisdom, maturity, and happiness seem to go hand in hand with figuring out how life and the world work — with discovering the nature of the rules, laws, and programming that dictate what will happen under what conditions. Wise people know that the more deeply and accurately they come to understand key processes within and without, the better able they are to live their personal lives in harmony with what is happening moment-to-moment. Wise people want to find out. Wise people are reality seekers.”

In A Guide for the Perplexed Schumacher comments that “the traditional wisdom of all peoples in all parts of the world . . . [has] become virtually incomprehensible to modern man.” He states that “traditional wisdom, including all the great religions, has always described itself as ‘The Way’ and given some kind of awakening as the goal.” He frequently refers to other religions or quotes varied religious thinkers and mystics like Buddha, the Muslim Sufi poet Rumi, Lao-tzu (founder of Taoism), as well as Christians like the medieval Thomas Aquinas and older Western philosophers such as Socrates, Plato,  and Aristotle. He even includes writers like Dante and Shakespeare as “outstanding representatives” of traditional wisdom. By the final decades of his life, he had concluded that “it may conceivably be possible to live without churches; but it is not possible to live without religion, that is, without systematic work to keep in contact with, and develop toward, Higher Levels than those of “ordinary life” with all its pleasure or pain, sensation, gratification, refinement or crudity—whatever it may be.”

Schumacher thought that traditional wisdom provided answers to such questions as “What is man? Where does he come from? What is the purpose of his life?” Wisdom “was directed primarily ‘towards the sovereign good,’ i.e., the True, the Good, and the Beautiful, knowledge of which would bring both happiness and salvation,” and it “looked upon nature as God's handiwork and man's mother.” He thought it could “be found only inside oneself. To be able to find it, one has first to liberate oneself from such masters as greed and envy. The stillness following liberation— even if only momentary— produces the insights of wisdom which are obtainable in no other way.”

Schumacher shared Aquinas’s view that wisdom “rightly judges all things and sets them in order.” Whether considering economics, science, technology, politics, the environment, or our own personal life, he thought that wisdom based on the highest values should guide our choices.

He wrote of what he called “Divergent problems.” They involved reconciling opposites such as justice and mercy, “stability and change, tradition and innovation, public interest and private interest, planning and laissez-faire, order and freedom, growth and decay.” He believed that “everywhere society’s health depends on the simultaneous pursuit of [such] mutually opposed activities or aims” and that “no real understanding is possible without awareness of these pairs of opposites which permeate everything man does.” The way to reconcile them was through “such higher forces as love and compassion, understanding and empathy,” and most importantly, wisdom.

To Schumacher’s mind, achieving and being guided by wisdom was the key to solving modern problems. Unless they were guided by wisdom all the scientific and technological inventions and economic thinking of the modern age would do little good. And he gave an example of how wisdom would guide one field of knowledge (economics) when he wrote that “from an economic point of view, the central concept of wisdom is permanence,” which today we would label sustainability.

To summarize Schumacher’s thinking on wisdom:

  • It can be found amidst the ideas of the great religious and philosophical systems of the pre-modern age.
  • It deals with fundamental questions like “What is the purpose of life?” and how to discover and achieve Truth, Goodness, and Beauty.
  • To find it one must first purify oneself from evils like greed and envy.
  • It emphasizes and applies higher values such as love, compassion, understanding, and empathy.
  • Being guided by it is the key to dealing with our most serious problems, whether economic, environmental, political, or personnel.

How Schumacher’s wisdom can help us in the 21st Century

Today, the world, developing and developed, North and South, East and West, is facing not one meltdown but many simultaneous meltdowns: financial meltdown, nuclear meltdown, ecological degradation, huge economic inequality and disparity, human rights abuses, family breakdown, child neglect, wars, terrorism, bloodshed and death. At the same time, consumerism and materialism has destroyed the fabric of society. The political, business, banking and yes, religious scandals have led to a total lack of trust. Every thing is centred on money.

What these crises have in common is a reckless disregard for the future--especially in the way the economy is run. Creating a sustainable economy--having enough to be happy without cheating the future—although not easy- is what is needed now. We need to learn again to love the world, nature, friendship, dialogue, laughter and joy. We must learn again what it means to be happy and which path to take to find it.

In short, as the world seems to teeter on the edge of catastrophe, we are fearfully beginning to wonder, “What on earth is to be done?” Particularly speaking, the disasters in Japan, the revolutions in the Middle East, the financial, economics and environmental crises, everywhere, demand an answer to this urgent, even desperate, question. There is no doubt that, we should see this multitude of crises as a wakeup call to see things as they are. We should search with an open mind for the wisdom we need to transform our economic system to a sustainable path, grounded in ecological reality, with respect for justice and dignity for all, and our appreciation for nature and our kinship for all living things. What is needed is nothing less than a new economic myth, grounded in wisdom to guide us safely to a better and more harmonious future.

Schumacher’s wisdom could not be more relevant at the time when the Doomsday Clock edges forward and we fear we are moving closer than ever towards nuclear Armageddon, irreversible global warming, financial meltdown and crises of amorality and spiritual breakdown, amongst others.

Schumacher always attempted to apply wisdom to numerous aspects of twentieth-century life, not only to economics and the environment, but to science, technology, culture, education, religion, and the relations of rich nations to poor nations. We shall return later to his ideas, but first a little bit of biographical and background is necessary.

E.F. Schumacher: A life in brief

Ernst Friedrich Schumacher was born in Germany in 1911. A Rhodes Scholar at Oxford in the 1930’s, he fled back to England before the Second World War to avoid living under Nazism. Although Schumacher was interned as an enemy alien during the War, his extraordinary abilities were recognized, and he was able to help the British government with its economic and financial mobilization.

After the War, E. F. Schumacher worked as an economic advisor to the British Control Commission charged with rebuilding the German economy. From 1950 to 1970 he was Chief Economic Advisor to the British Coal Board, one of the world’s largest organizations, with 800,000 employees. Schumacher's farsighted planning (he predicted the rise of OPEC and the problems of nuclear power) aided Britain in its economic recovery.

In 1955 Schumacher travelled to Burma as an economic consultant. While there, he developed the principles of what he called “Buddhist economics,” based on the belief that good work was essential for proper human development and that “production from local resources for local needs is the most rational way of economic life.” Schumacher also gained insights that led him to become a pioneer of what is now called "appropriate technology": earth- and user-friendly technology matched to the scale of community life.

E. F. Schumacher subsequently became a featured writer—along with Leopold Kohr, John Papworth, Danilo Dolci, Paul Goodman, John Seymour, and Satish Kumar in the British Journal Resurgence. He also extensively and frequently wrote articles for the Guardian and the Observer. His books and other writings have influenced many readers to re-examine societal and personal choices regarding the persistent demands of modern life.

Schumacher’s Wisdom on Education

As it has been noted by many observers including Moss, Schumacher believed that “more education can help us only if it produces more wisdom.” He was very critical of what has eventually became the dominant purpose of higher education—career preparation for work in our modern industrial societies, which he believed were deeply flawed. 

The main problem he perceived with modern education was that it had abandoned the search for wisdom. In A Guide for the Perplexed, he indicated the difficulties he faced trying to discover how best to live. “All through school and university I had been given maps of life and knowledge on which there was hardly a trace of many of the things that I most cared about and that seemed to me to be of the greatest possible importance to the conduct of my life.” These “maps” he referred to were those “produced by modern materialistic scientism . . . [that left] all the questions that really matter unanswered.” He went on to note that the situation was “even worse now because the ever more rigorous application of the scientific method to all subjects and disciplines has destroyed even the last remnants of ancient wisdom— at least in the Western world. It is being loudly proclaimed in the name of scientific objectivity that ‘values and meanings are nothing but defence mechanisms and reaction formations.’"

Schumacher maintained that what people really needed were “ideas that would make the world, and their own lives, intelligible to them. . . . If the mind cannot bring to the world a set—or, shall we say, a tool-box—of powerful ideas, the world must appear to it as a chaos, a mass of unrelated phenomena, of meaningless events.”

According to Schumacher, “Our task—and the task of all education—is to understand the present world, the world in which we live and make our choices. The problems of education are merely reflections of the deepest problems of our age. They cannot be solved by organization, administration, or the expenditure of money, even though the importance of all these is not denied. We are suffering from a metaphysical disease, and the cure must therefore be metaphysical. Education which fails to clarify our central convictions is mere training or indulgence. For it is our central convictions that are in disorder, and, as long as the present anti-metaphysical temper persists, the disorder will grow worse. Education, far from ranking as man's greatest resource, will then be an agent of destruction”.

Science, he wrote, “cannot produce ideas by which we could live,” and it was “being taught without any awareness of the . . . place occupied by the natural sciences within the whole cosmos of human thought.” Although he recognized that the sciences conveyed important information “about how things work in nature or in engineering,” they conveyed “nothing about the meaning of life.” In regard to two “social sciences,” he wrote that economics was “being taught without any awareness of the view of human nature that underlies present-day economic theory,” and politics without considering the “metaphysical and ethical problems involved” in dealing with human interaction.

At first glance the humanities seemed to offer some hope, Schumacher notes—“here indeed he [the student] can find, if he is lucky, great and vital ideas to fill his mind, ideas with which to think and through which to make the world, society, and his own life intelligible.” Unfortunately, however, “even in the humanities we may get bogged down in a mass of specialised scholarship furnishing our minds with lots of small ideas just as unsuitable as the ideas which we might pick up from the natural sciences.” Or the humanities might present to us “a view of the world as a wasteland in which there is no meaning or purpose, in which man's consciousness is an unfortunate cosmic accident, in which anguish and despair are the only final realities.”

For education to help us develop the greatest wisdom as Moss notes, Schumacher thought it had to assist us in developing our values. “Education cannot help us as long as it accords no place to metaphysics. Whether the subjects taught are subjects of science or of the humanities, if the teaching does not lead to a clarification of metaphysics, that is to say, of our fundamental convictions, it cannot educate a man and, consequently, cannot be of real value to society.”

Schumacher continually emphasized the traditional values taught by the great world religions, but also emphasized that these “values do not help us to pick our way through life unless they have become our own, a part, so to say, of our mental make-up.” He added that individuals had to interiorize what they were taught, they had to “sift it, sort it out, keep the good and jettison the bad” in order to become inner directed. Education for wisdom, however, still had to help an individual accomplish one more task—“dying to oneself . . . to all one's egocentric preoccupations.” He went on to say that to be happy and wise there were three things that people “most need to do and education ought to prepare them for these things: To act as spiritual beings, that is to say, to act in accordance with their moral impulses. . . . To act as neighbours, to render service . . . . [and] to act as persons, as autonomous centres of power and responsibility, that is, to be creatively engaged, using and developing the gifts that we have been blessed with.”

To Schumacher our values lie at the core of our being, affecting how we approach all subjects. As he notes:

“All subjects, no matter how specialised, are connected with a centre; they are like rays emanating from a sun. The centre is constituted by our most basic convictions, by those ideas which really have the power to move us. In other words, the centre consists of metaphysics and ethics, of ideas that— whether we like it or not— transcend the world of facts. Because they transcend the world of facts, they cannot be proved or disproved by ordinary scientific method. But that does not mean that they are purely “subjective” or “relative” or mere arbitrary conventions. They must be true to reality, although they transcend the world of facts. . . .

Education can help us only if it produces “whole men”, Schumacher observed. The truly educated man is not a man who knows a bit of everything . . . but he will be truly in touch with the centre. He will not be in doubt about his basic convictions, about his view on the meaning and purpose of his life. He may not be able to explain these matters in words, but the conduct of his life will show a certain sureness of touch which stems from his inner clarity”.

Thus, he thought that the study of all subjects should be penetrated by the rays of our values, of our wisdom. “Unless that person has sorted out and coordinated his manifold urges, impulses, and desires, his strivings are likely to be confused, contradictory, self-defeating, and possibly highly destructive. The ‘centre,’ obviously, is the place where he has to create for himself an orderly system of ideas about himself and the world, which can regulate the direction of his various strivings.”

Rather than educating people to fit into modern economic systems that were unsustainable, Schumacher hoped that “higher education could be designed to lead to a different world of work.” It could help students “distinguish between good work and bad work and encourage them not to accept the latter. That is to say, they should be encouraged to reject meaningless, boring, stultifying, or nerve-racking work in which a man (or woman) is made the servant of a machine or a system. They should be taught that work is the joy of life and is needed for our development, but that meaningless work is an abomination.” He also believed that those lucky enough to receive higher education in poorer parts of the world should not use it to help them distance themselves from their poorer countrymen, but to help them.

Schumacher’s Wisdom on Economics and Industrial Society

As Moss has so eloquently observed, Schumacher stated that economics dominated government policies and “absorbs almost the whole of foreign policy” and the “whole of ethics” and takes “precedence over all other human considerations. Now, quite clearly, this is a pathological development.” It was so, Schumacher believed, because the dominant economics of his day had long deviated from any attempt at being guided by wisdom. In his chapter on “Buddhist Economics” in Small Is Beautiful he indicated his belief that the dominant Western economics was not the only possible approach to a field that many thought of as a science, or at least a “social science.” In writing about Western economics, he also made it clear that he believed it was not only contrary to Buddhist economics, but to some basic Christian principles, as well as to the world’s traditional wisdom.

He insisted that economics was essentially different than a science like physics— “the great majority of economists are still pursuing the absurd ideal of making their 'science' as scientific and precise as physics, as if there were no qualitative difference between mindless atoms and men made in the image of God.” He believed that economics was strongly influenced, whether one realized it or not, by one’s philosophical or religious views, by what he called meta-economics. By the term he meant to indicate “that economics must derive its aims and objectives from a study of man, and that it must derive at least a large part of its methodology from a study of nature.” In “Buddhist Economics” he attempted to indicate “how the conclusions and prescriptions of economics change as the underlying picture of man and his purpose on earth changes.”

Schumacher believed that modern Western economics reflected a materialist approach. “Out of the large number of aspects which in real life have to be seen and judged together before a decision can be taken, economics supplies only one—whether a thing yields a money profit to those who undertake it or not.” It does not even generally ask “whether an activity carried on by a group within society yields a profit to society as a whole. . . . In a sense, the market is the institutionalisation of individualism and non-responsibility.” With its emphasis on rapid change, economic growth, and increasing Gross National Product (GNP), Western economics failed to adequately consider “the availability of basic resources and, alternatively or additionally, the capacity of the environment to cope with the degree of interference implied.” By advertising and marketing, it also encouraged a “frenzy of greed and . . . an orgy of envy.” Schumacher observed that by ignoring wisdom humans were in danger of building up “a monster economy, which destroys the world.”

He also wrote that “the cultivation and expansion of needs is the antithesis of wisdom, . . . freedom and peace. Every increase of needs tends to increase one's dependence on outside forces over which one cannot have control, and therefore increases existential fear. Only by a reduction of needs can one promote a genuine reduction in those tensions which are the ultimate causes of strife and war.”

Buddhist economics, he thought, would take a different approach. He wrote that “while the materialist is mainly interested in goods, the Buddhist is mainly interested in liberation. “Whereas a Western economist would measure “the 'standard of living' by the amount of annual consumption, assuming . . . that a man who consumes more is 'better off' than a man who consumes less,” a Buddhist economist would think that “the aim should be to obtain the maximum of well-being with the minimum of consumption.”

Another major difference was that, unlike most Western economic thinking, a Buddhist approach would take a more sustainable approach to natural resources—“Non- renewable goods must be used only if they are indispensable, and then only with the greatest care and the most meticulous concern for conservation.”

Given Schumacher’s approach to Western economics, his criticism of modern industrial society, whether capitalist, socialist, or communist, is understandable. In “the light of the Gospels,” he thought it guilty of “four great and grievous evils”:

  1. Its vastly complicated nature.
  2. Its continuous stimulation of, and reliance on, the deadly sins of greed, envy, and avarice.
  3. Its destruction of the content and dignity of most forms of work.
  4. Its authoritarian character, owing to organization in excessively large units.

In keeping with this perspective, he furnished five reasons why he thought modern industrial society should fail:

  1. It has disrupted, and continues to disrupt, certain organic relationships in such a manner that world population is growing, apparently irresistibly, beyond the means of subsistence.
  2. It is disrupting certain other organic relationships in such a manner as to threaten those means of subsistence themselves, spreading poison, adulterating food, etc.
  3. It is rapidly depleting the earth's non-renewable stocks of scarce mineral resources—mainly fuels and metals.
  4. It is degrading the moral and intellectual qualities of man while further developing a highly complicated way of life the smooth continuance of which requires ever-increasing moral and intellectual qualities.
  5. It breeds violence— violence against nature which at any moment can turn into violence against one's fellow men, when there are weapons around which make non-violence a condition of survival.

Such a sweeping critique, as Moss has remarked, was indeed radical because it challenged many of the premises of modern industrial societies, whether they called themselves capitalist, socialist, or communist. All three, for example, emphasized economic growth as demonstrated by GNP increases. Whereas they attempted to expand the production of material goods, Schumacher emphasized the spiritual and environmental consequences of constantly expanding “wants.” He recommended “resisting the temptation of letting our luxuries become needs; and perhaps . . . even scrutinising our needs to see if they cannot be simplified and reduced.” Of course, he distinguished between basic needs and what he considered artificial “needs” that were really “wants.” He worked hard to help meet the basic needs of poorer peoples, but he believed that “poor people have relatively simple needs, and it is primarily with regard to their basic requirements and activities that they want assistance.”

As fair-minded observers with an eye on natural justice, truth and reality, given the current global crises, we can only say how prophetic the above observations by Schumacher were and indeed, are. How tragic it must be that we did not heed his words and did not grasp the power of his wisdom. However, it is not too late to discover Schumacher and to heed to his wisdom and recommendations. They have stood the test of times.

Legacy and Concluding Remarks

Once again, referring to the excellent study by Moss, we can observe that everywhere we look; a decade into the 21st Century, Schumacher’s influence is readily evident for all to see.

In England there is the Schumacher Circle, which is described well on the web site of Resurgence, which is today a non-profit trust that oversees the publication of a magazine of the same name and one to which Schumacher contributed decades ago. The web site states:

There are many organizations that owe their existence to, or have been greatly inspired by, E.F. Schumacher. His books and other writings are still thought-provoking. . . . The range of his thinking is reflected in the diversity of the organisations that recognise him as their inspiration: they share a vision of social development that is sustainable and benign to both people and the environment.

The Schumacher Circle comprises:

  • Green Books
  • Practical Action
  • The New Economics Foundation
  • Resurgence Magazine
  • Schumacher College
  • The Schumacher Society
  • Schumacher Book Service
  • The Soil Association

“It is an informal network of organizations which in their different ways all build on Schumacher’s legacy. They have a common concern with developing ideas and approaches to the ecological, technological, social and spiritual predicament which is faced by the world’s population.”

Several of the groups mentioned above were ones that Schumacher founded or was very active in such as Practical Action, earlier called the Intermediate Technology Development Group, and the Soil Association. The editor of Resurgence, Satish Kumar, has recently described a bit of his involvement when still young with Schumacher and has written that his “Small is Beautiful gave a philosophical, spiritual and economic grounding to the environmental movement.” Besides the British organizations mentioned above, there are Schumacher societies in several other countries, including a very active one in the United States.

Besides Schumacher’s influence on the environmental movement, he has also had a noticeable effect on thinking about developmental aid to poor countries, though often not as much on official government aid programs as on non-governmental ones. Until recently, however, as Moss observes, his impact on main-stream economics has not been especially noticeable. But in recent years the ideas of some leading economists have come closer to those that he emphasized decades ago.

The best example of this is the 2009 report commissioned by French President Nicholas Sarkozy and headed by Nobel-Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz with the able assistance of others including another recipient of the prize, Harvard economist Amartya Sen. Although, As Moss has noted, there is no mention of Schumacher in the 291-page document, sometimes called the Stiglitz-Sen report, it recommends many steps Schumacher first advocated decades ago.

In the “Executive Summary” before the body of the report, its authors pose the question: “What are the main messages and recommendations?” To which they reply:

The report distinguishes between an assessment of current well-being and an assessment of sustainability, whether this can last over time. Current well-being has to do with both economic resources, such as income, and with non-economic aspects of peoples’ life (what they do and what they can do, how they feel, and the natural environment they live in). Whether these levels of well-being can be sustained over time depends on whether stocks of capital that matter for our lives (natural, physical, human, social) are passed on to future generations.

The summary also states that “another key message, and unifying theme of the report, is that the time is ripe for our measurement system to shift emphasis from measuring economic production to measuring people’s well-being.”

Time and again Schumacher had insisted on conclusions this report arrived at more than three decades after his death: using economic growth rates as a measurement of a country’s success was misleading; countries placed too much emphasis on increasing production; and economists and government officials had to pay more attention to the environment and sustainability.

Besides the Stiglitz-Sen report, another long document that reflects many of Schumacher’s ideas—again without mentioning him—is the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) 2008 report of 352 pages entitled Green Jobs: Towards Decent Work in a Sustainable, Low-Carbon World. These two reports followed up on an increasing trend toward criticizing an over-reliance on economic growth (as measured by GDP increases) as a standard for improved well-being.

In a recent study in The Observer (Sunday 27 March 2011) Tony Helm and Robert McCrum in their articles, “Small is beautiful: the father of David Cameron’s big society” and “EF Schumacher: Cameron’s choice” respectively, have highlighted the impact of Schumacher on the British prime minister, David Cameron’s socio-political and economic philosophy and his vision of “The Big Society”. Only time can tell how truthful Cameron is in following Schumacher’s wisdom.

Most interestingly, it seems that some of the captain’s of industry and business gurus are heeding Schumacher’s call for social responsibility, ethics and serving various “stakeholders” and not just adhering to the interest of the shareholders. It appears that these business leaders are discovering the wisdom of Schumacher that a more radical approach is called for if humanity is to be best served by business and economic activity.

Writing recently in the Guardian Sustainable Business, Ian Cheshire, the CEO of one of UK’s largest DIY retail chain, Kingfisher/B&Q, in an article, “Imagining a new, sustainable capitalism” noted that:

…”I believe that we are now faced with the need for real reinvention of our high resource-impact business models, and that those leadership businesses that rethink their future will benefit in the next wave of change.

Starting with need for change, in a world of $100 a barrel oil, business models assuming an implicit abundance of free resources cannot by definition be sustainable. The stress on the natural capital in our world, the impacts on ecosystems such as forests, reefs and fisheries are producing major changes in costs and supply of materials for all businesses.

Infinite high resource intensity growth is simply not possible, and we are already living off our future capital. It may be gradual but most businesses  will have to adjust to a very different reality.

…Instead of the goal of maximum linear growth in GDP, we should be thinking of maximum wellbeing for minimal planetary input. That starts to challenge business to go beyond efficiency gains, useful though they are, and really redesign their business models.

…The wellbeing challenge also forces us to think about our total impact as a business rather than the narrow shareholder value lens, since businesses that do not create broader social value will again not survive the longer term.”

In a further positive and timely development Sir Stuart Rose, outgoing chairman of Marks & Spencer, has warned that companies will need to radically alter their business models if they are going to cope with a perfect storm of climate change, a growing global population, and finite resources.

Speaking at the Royal Geographical Society as part of the 21st Century Challenges series, he said: "For all the hard work we have had to date, we probably only think we've done about 10% of what we need to do to build a truly sustainable Marks & Spencer, so the job ahead is pretty enormous.

"We have to change, not a little, but radically. Not later, but now. Not with today's business thinking but with a new set of skills. And we have to do this with energy and we have to understand that there is no plan B, as there isn't in Marks & Spencer.

"Certainly there will be some businesses that survive with unsustainable business models. They will survive for another decade, they may survive for two decades. But eventually, even those of us who recognise the need for change cannot underestimate the scale of change we need to make or the duration of time it's going to need to make the change we need to do. So we need to start now.

"We will have to deal with extraordinary complexity and ambiguity and there are, and will be, no simple answers. But there will certainly be less of the yes/no decision making.

"Business leadership in the future will be about discerning and communicating a direction through this minefield of complexities. There are going to be natural disasters, there are going to be uncertainties in supplies of resources, and these are problems that we are all going to have to deal with."

Rose echoed the views of others that there will need to be increasing collaboration between business, NGOs and governments as no single company had the answers to the range of problems they face.

"Now this in turn will allow us to innovate faster, to respond to the sustainability crunch, and it will turn risk into commercial opportunity ahead of the wave, and that's the challenge we've all got to face if we are going to be on a planet we want to live in 30, 40, 50 years time," Rose remarked.

He also said that City investors are starting to recognise the importance of taking a longer-term view, rather than just concentrating on short-term profits: "It was absolutely the case that when I first raised sustainability with some of my investors, they literally threw their hands up in horror and said 'how can you spend £200m without getting a guaranteed return on your capital invested?' Now they know that it's an imperative and it's going to be part of how businesses differentiate and succeed in the future. So I actually think it is changing. It's a bit behind but it's changing."

I do hope that many other CEOs will discover the wisdom of what Schumacher had shared with us all those decades ago and follow the examples of Ian Cheshire, Sir Stuart Rose and others like them.

In conclusion, paraphrasing the wise conclusion by Moss, today, more than three decades after Schumacher’s death, many of the problems he faced are similar to ones we now confront.  At a time when technology, economics, and the environment continue to be as important as Schumacher believed they were decades ago, and at a time when decisions about them are still often made unwisely, we need to remind ourselves that such decisions need to be made as Schumacher insisted they should—in keeping with the highest human values.

Epilogue: E.F. Schumacher and I

“Gratitude is heaven itself”-William Blake

I owe my fascination with the inner workings of economics, business and capitalism to those who have inspired me both personally and professionally. I am a blessed man to have been inspired by so many sages and philosophers of love and compassion, amongst them:

E.F Schumacher, John Kenneth Galbraith, Henry George, George Bull, Herman Daly, John B. Cobb Jr, Dalai Lama, R.H. Tawney, Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill, Aristotle, St Augustine of Hippo, St Thomas Aquinas, St Francis of Assisi, Abu Hamid al-Ghazali, Maulana Jalaluddin Rumi, and Shams-ud-din Mohammad Hafez Shirazi.

I have given my thanks and gratitude to many who have inspired me in my lectures, books and articles. Today, here, in this essay, I wish to convey my special gratitude to E.F. Schumacher in celebration of his centenary.

Above in my introductory remarks I noted how Schumacher became a source of inspiration to me from that day in 1979 that I bought his book, ‘Small is Beautiful: Economics as if people mattered.’ I know well with the philosophical and spiritual truths that I hold dear, how important Schumacher has been to my personal and professional development. I may not have known this fully. But, recently I have become more aware and more conscious of it. This is more so, since the time in late 1990s that I “rediscovered” myself when I changed direction, became a different, and I sincerely hope, a better economist, teacher, and overall, a better person. All these were manifested when I founded the Globalisation for the Common Good Initiative in 2002. See below for an example of Schumacher’s thinking on me:

Globalisation for the Common Good Initiative (GCGI)

GCGI: An Overview

GCGI: Mission and Vision

Furthermore, and similar to Schumacher, I have also been much concerned about people’s happiness and general well-being. I, too, have been saying that economic policies are only successful if they enhance happiness and well-being. This is why I recently launched the GCGI “Happiness and Well-being Project”:

Why Happiness Should be Taught at Our Universities

Moreover, like Schumacher I have been critical of the economics curriculum and the way it is taught at our universities. I have also been critical of the value-free MBAs. See below for my contributions in furthering the debate that Schumacher had begun in early 70s:

Economics, Globalisation and the Common Good: A Lecture at LondonSchool of Economics

Calling all academic economists: What are you teaching your students?

My Economics and Business Educators’ Oath: My Promise to My Students

In Conclusion, for me, Schumacher’s charming innocence, universal compassion and thirst for true knowledge mark him out as a teacher in the great traditions of religious and philosophical sages who embrace the one universal truth.  He was – and still is- a giant among men, who truly deserves to be described as a friend to mankind, renaissance man, and bridge of reconciliation between cultures.

I thank Schumacher for inspiring me and countless others. God grant Schumacher eternal rest; he was, in the old idiom, a lovely man, who if required, may still be a peacemaker in heaven.

References used in writing this article:

E.F. Schumacher, Small is Beautiful: Economics as if people mattered, Bland & Briggs, London, 1973

­___ A Guide for the Perplexed, Jonathan Cape, London, 1977

___ Good Work, Jonathan Cape, London, 1979

Walter G. Moss, “The Wisdom of E.F. Schumacher” at http://www.wisdompage.com/SchumacherEssay.pdf (I am indebted to Moss for his excellent work which I borrowed much in this study on Schumacher’s wisdom)

Robert McCrum, “EF Schumacher: Cameron’s choice” in The Observer, Sunday 27 March 2011

Tony Helm, “Small is beautiful: the father of David Cameron’s big society” in The Observer, Sunday 27 March 2011

Jo Confino, “Stuart Rose warns companies must radically change – and work together” in the Guardian Sustainable Business, The Guardian, Thursday 2 December 2010

Ian Cheshire, “Imagining a new, sustainable capitalism” in the Guardian Sustainable Business, The Guardian, Tuesday 30 March 2011

Martin Hodgson, “Big, bad world” in The Guardian, Wednesday 27 August 2003

John Fullerton, “The Relevance of E.F. Schumacher in the 21st Century” at http://neweconomicsinstitute.org/publications/essays/fullerton/john/the-relevance-of-ef-schumacher-in-the-21st-century

Further reading:

Small is Beautiful in the 21st Century: The Legacy of E.F. Schumacher (Schumacher Briefings) Paperback 8 Oct 2011

By Diana Schumacher

Small is Beautiful in the 21st Century traces Fritz Schumacher’s legacy through the activities and outreach of those pioneers who, over the years, have been working on practical solutions to our interrelated global crises. In particular, it describes how several flourishing organisations, some large and some small, have remained closely linked with his ideas and work, and have since become associated as the Schumacher Circle.
 
The particular contribution of E. F. Schumacher was to bring a profound wisdom and humanity to bear on the practical challenges of our time, and the Briefing both illuminates Schumacher’s thinking and shows the ways in which each of us can help to turn our present crisis into the opportunity to build a more kind, just and ecologically sustainable society.

Contents
Who was Fritz Schumacher?
The Schumacher Society
Third World development models
Food, agriculture and land use
Small-scale technologies for local sustainability
The call for a new economics
Transforming industrial work in the First World
The relevance of E. F. Schumacher today

For more details and to purchase this book:

Green Books - Small is Beautiful in the 21st Century

Go to top
Notice: Undefined index: adv in /home/kamranmofid/public_html/templates/jsn_epic_pro/index.php on line 654
cialis 20 mg fiyat cialis express delivery cialis retail cost bangkok cialis where to buy free cialis trial voucher cialis generico 10 mg precio cialis diario cialis generico foro cialis trial voucher order cialis with paypal cialis and l-arginine prezzo cialis 20 mg in farmacia buy cheap cialis online uk cialis 5 mg filmtabletten cost cialis nz antibiotics and cialis cialis asli can i take 20mg of cialis levitra preturi how long does levitra take to work online levitra reviews levitra generico mexico is generic levitra effective levitra bester preis levitra en costa rica levitra pakistan levitra generika rezeptfrei buy levitra over counter buy levitra europe levitra 2.5 mg efeitos colaterais do levitra levitra how often levitra efeitos colaterais levitra kaufen billig levitra english levitra dosage 20mg brand levitra 20mg levitra headaches walgreens levitra price levitra canada pharmacy online levitra ads generic levitra sale maximum dose levitra generic levitra best price best price levitra generic flomax levitra when do you take levitra levitra wirkungseintritt levitra works best levitra 10 mg online levitra prix en france levitra testimonials cost of levitra in canada recommended dosage of levitra levitra for sale in uk levitra france prix bayer levitra precio price of levitra at walgreens levitra online pharmacy canada best prices on generic levitra levitra in thailand levitra and headaches levitra for sale uk buy levitra 10mg how long does it take levitra to work levitra prostate levitra color levitra how long does it take to work levitra pics how long does it take for levitra to work generic levitra effective levitra 10 mg filmtabletten levitra dosage recommended cheapest levitra canada buy generic levitra from canada levitra costa rica levitra depression levitra actress cvs levitra recommended dosage levitra levitra company levitra reactions levitra dangers levitra bodybuilding where to buy levitra over the counter levitra pen cost levitra canada costo del levitra do i need a prescription for levitra levitra online sales levitra for females price for levitra at walgreens levitra and atenolol cheap canadian levitra best place to buy levitra facts about levitra levitra facts levitra and adderall price of levitra walgreens levitra 5 mg costo levitra walgreens price best price for levitra online levitra maximum dose women take levitra levitra cost canada levitra sydney free generic levitra levitra everyday what is the shelf life of levitra 20mg levitra dosage recommended levitra dosage levitra thailand levitra sale uk levitra nz levitra 10mg or 20mg levitra tablet price what does levitra look like comprare levitra generico best place buy levitra levitra and ibuprofen levitra 10 mg vs 20 mg levitra 10 bucodispersable levitra te koop levitra lasts levitra shelf life levitra cvs levitra 20mg pills levitra voucher effective time for viagra effects side viagra woman explanation of viagra eyesight cialis female viagra for men generic cialis mexican generic money order viagra generic viagra caverta cialis cheap generic viagra companies generic viagra money order generic viagra pages edinburgh get discount viagra online get viagra at an online pharmacy ginko viagra how cialis works for me how to get viagra without perscription i took too much viagra information dosage viagra inr and viagra internet sales viagra is there a viagra alternative junk email viagra mark martin viagra mccain viagra video mexican generic cialis mixing cocaine and viagra mixing viagra and cocaine multiple erections with viagra natural testosterone viagra naturens viagra need perscription viagra no erection viagra online meds cialis pages edinburgh search viagra free parody of cialis pay shipping for viagra paypal pfizer viagra prescrition for viagra price of viagra medicine psa viagra q a viagra qa viagra que efectos produce el viagra questions and answers about viagra redtube viagra search viagra viagra find 76k buy sex without viagra snort cialis the best natural viagra alternative tricare viagra usa online pharmacies viagra vasodilator viagra viagra 50m viagra alike viagra and eating a meal viagra and lasting longer viagra and relationships viagra and toprol viagra bp viagra buyer viagra cheap express viagra difference in mg viagra direction viagra dose use how to viagra doseage viagra scams viagra edinburgh search site find viagra efects viagra enhancements viagra facial viagra for pet viagra fucks viagra ginko viagra in baltimore viagra in chewing gum viagra interaction with muscle relaxant viagra lasting longer viagra lavitra cialis viagra medicamentos similares viagra multiple erections viagra online without prescription overnight viagra oz viagra pens viagra photos viagra pro review viagra producer viagra retail discount viagra sales online in uk viagra samples free generic viagra tie viagra time effective viagra tribulus viagra vascular viagra website official viagra without prescription milwaukee what is retail cost of cialis where to buy viagra in bahrain where to buy viagra in kent who markets viagra women take kamagra womens cialis xray viagra cialis erectile disfunction soft pill cialis cialis storage average cialis prices buy cheap cialis on the net buy cialis cialas buy cialis mail online buy cialis pills generic buy cialis softtabs online cheap generic cialis pills cheapest india generic cialis cialis 20 mg discount cialis dream online cialis effects information cialis europe viagra cialis free trial in canada cialis medication online cialis overnight shipment cialis pharmacy sell which cialis pills without a prescription cialis rss feed cialis soft tablet cialis tablets for men express delivery cialis generic cialis picture generic cialis pills cheap generic mexican cialis girls on cialis viagra contra cialis yasmin cialis cialis cialis no prescription mastercard cialis australia no prescription order cialis 20 mg cialis online america cuanto dura cialis no prescription cialis mastercard cheap generic cialis without a prescription gdzie kupic cialis review buy cialis online cialis puerto rico animals on viagra best buy buying online viagra viagra best pharmacy viagra price buy deal deal price viagra buy viagra cheap prices buy viagra online at cheap price buying viagra online noprescription cheap generic viagra from usa cheapest generic viagra and canada cut viagra pill side effects viagra eye problems viagra generic viagra with american express generic viagra with money order glucophage viagra grandpa on viagra is viagra safe for woman liver disease viagra london viagra without prescription lowest cost generic viagra mixing cocaine with viagra mixing viagra with cocaine multiple erections viagra natural viagras no prescription viagra sample order mexican viagra piadas de viagra piadas viagra query viagra red pill viagra safe viagra woman us discount viagra vega generic viagra viagra and celias viagra blue big love viagra buy general viagra celias viagra discount retail viagra from canada legitimate viagra from health store viagra herbario viagra onlines viagra pfitzer viagra pharmacy london viagra pill splitters viagra prevent premature ejaculation viagra propecia buy online viagra woman side effects free sites computer search viagra viagra tv ad generic viagra au viagra cheap au australian viagra paypal buy viagra with paypal canada viagra in sacramento buy viagra generic 100mg generic viagra pro dp viagra order viagra without a rx viagra for sale in can brand viagra in australia viagra -p-force buy viagra in australia with paypal buy viagra in milwaukee free viagra online without prescription kamagra review forum kamagra in south africa kamagra kopen in winkel kamagra articles kamagra pills uk kamagra net uk caverta kamagra cheap kamagra uk online kamagra quick co uk kamagra oral jelly usa kamagra aus deutschland bestellen kamagra directions real kamagra kamagra fizz kamagra generique is kamagra dangerous kamagra blue pill kamagra sur paris kamagra free delivery kamagra norge kamagra dosis kamagra oral jelly wirkung buy kamagra jelly uk low cost kamagra kamagra 100 effervescent kamagra 200mg kamagra quick delivery kamagra spain kamagra shop erfahrung kamagra greece kamagra effetti kamagra forum review kamagra kamagra bez recepty cheap kamagra online uk comprar kamagra jelly kamagra gel buy ajanta kamagra oral jelly erectile dysfunction kamagra kamagra super force kamagra erfahrung forum buy kamagra canada kamagra bestellen deutschland kamagra oral jelly from india kamagra oral jelly ajanta kamagra effervescent 100 kamagra ajanta oral jelly kamagra pictures kamagra in deutschland bestellen kamagra sildenafil citrate 100mg kamagra deutschland bestellen kamagra sildenafil citrate 100mg ' kamagra oral jelly in india womens viagra pills viagra ci vuole la ricetta viagra deutschland rezeptpflichtig donde comprar viagra en argentina 100 mg viagra reviews koktel viagra viagra in istanbul viagra prescription nz viagra how long does it take to kick in canadian generic viagra cheap viagra vente libre pharmacie tesco viagra prices legit generic viagra pink viagra uk buy viagra san francisco genuine generic viagra venta viagra barata buy viagra for women uk taking viagra young men indian viagra for women viagra billig online bestellen chest pain viagra viagra revenue official viagra website best pharmacy for generic viagra download 2 chainz viagra if you take viagra and dont need it dosis recomendadas de viagra viagra ajanta viagra para mujeres venta what does viagra feel like viagra powerpoint what side effect does viagra have buy viagra tablets uk viagra reductil manufacturer of viagra in india viagra pret farmacie buy generic viagra online from india viagra men videos viagra zollfrei herbal viagra sale viagra meaning in hindi cheapest place to get viagra selling viagra uk viagra pricing walmart can you buy viagra over the counter in usa manly viagra how does viagra work yahoo viagra celebrity cheap viagra ireland viagra sailboat viagra prescription information viagra sample pills atenolol viagra interaction viagra generique au canada cheap viagra without rx is 100mg of viagra safe health risks of viagra viagra on the high street get viagra malaysia betablocker viagra viagra and women blog viagra sold in stores viagra to improve performance mercury viagra viagra prescription boots viagra home remedies venta de viagra en santiago qual o melhor generico do viagra how long before you take viagra buy viagra in hyderabad viagra generic. walgreens comprar viagra en linea viagra and methamphetamine viagra vimax 50 is viagra sold in stores nasal viagra spray tegretol viagra viagra capsule price india best place to buy viagra in the uk buy viagra manchester how does viagra affect a woman viagra side effects long term use comprar viagra santiago brand name viagra no prescription viagra medco viagra pas cher france viagra rosario drinking and taking viagra viagra fiyat eczane viagra pink pill for women viagra price bangladesh viagra slovenija cuanto tiempo dura el efecto de la viagra viagra forum experiences viagra brussels pret viagra farmacie comprare viagra in svizzera oral viagra gel how to buy viagra in tijuana natural viagra australia viagra fast acting viagra society sample viagra pills thailand viagra gel viagra and acid reflux o viagra funciona mesmo dosage viagra should take can you overdose viagra can viagra stop premature ejaculation where to buy viagra in edinburgh pink pill for women viagra viagra store in pakistan viagra effects in urdu mild viagra long term use of viagra side effects buy viagra online org uk possession of viagra what dosage viagra should i take viagra hints who sells generic viagra preisvergleich viagra 50 mg is it legal to buy viagra online in canada buying viagra in dubai viagra head office toronto address viagra e ipertensione does viagra work yahoo united states online pharmacy viagra viagra in chennai prices viagra delhi stores viagra angleterre where can i buy viagra in edinburgh how long takes viagra to work viagra online bestellen forum generic viagra walgreens viagra prescription las vegas alternative pills to viagra viagra banner viagra year did come out prescription free viagra uk viagra tablets in india name safest generic viagra how does viagra feel like cialis 5 mg bestellen tadalafil cialis reviews how long does it take for cialis to take effect cialis for sale in the us achat cialis par paypal generic cialis walmart cialis distributor cialis tricare cialis with blood pressure medication cialis and cardura side effects of cialis 5 mg indigestion cialis cialis doctissimo forum cialis blood pressure medication comprar cialis usa how to take cialis for daily use best source cialis 10mg cialis review metoprolol and cialis internet pharmacy cialis is cialis good for you side effects of cialis 10mg cialis patents expire peut acheter cialis cialis soft review my cialis prescription cialis reflux cialis swelling cialis instructions for use how often can you use cialis generic cialis women cialis .99 cialis bestellen erfahrungen buy generic cialis online in usa cialis ranbaxy soft cialis reviews cialis vision loss cialis 5mg side effects naproxen cialis mechanism of action of cialis dangers of generic cialis tesco online viagra generi viagra over night viagra usa buy viagra on discover card levitrabuy levitra online discount levitra rx levitra expiry brand generic levitra name vs buy levitra online us interaction levitra levitra anxiety levitra interaction kamagra 100 forum kamagra 100mg oral jelly sildenafil kamagra jelly wikipedia kamagra for women oral jelly super kamagra bericht kamagra price in india cheap kamagra pills kamagra oral jelly 100mg sildenafil buy kamagra fast kamagra ebay k fast kamagra buy kamagra pay with paypal kamagra jelin yan etkileri 1000 ways to die viagra overdose viagra tablets women india buying viagra canada no prescription viagra tablet for man how long does it take for a viagra to take effect viagra pasteque viagra models comprar viagra en peru per il viagra ci vuole la ricetta comprar viagra sin receta argentina viagra 50 mg forum is viagra any good what happens if i take viagra and i don't need it viagra contact number is taking viagra safe where to buy viagra in shanghai venta viagra natural generic viagra sildenafil citrate 100mg how to get free viagra online viagra dhaka viagra upset stomach viagra in pakistan stores viagra herbal ultimate herbal buying viagra bangkok cheap viagra deals cheapest generic viagra 100mg viagra online kaufen forum where to buy viagra in hyderabad viagra in south korea viagra presion arterial for pde5 viagra sildenafil is a can i buy viagra in germany stay up viagra kanye west buying viagra online forums safe website to buy viagra viagra increase blood pressure online uk pharmacies viagra how long does it take viagra to take effect does viagra have a generic viagra gold coast discount online pharmacy viagra best us viagra price viagra sales pfizer viagra pretoria does viagra make me last longer name of viagra tablets in india red generic viagra viagra femme pharmacie pastillas de viagra comprar get viagra quick viagra ireland over the counter best price for viagra in us viagra pharmacy ireland ghb viagra buy viagra shanghai comment fonctionne le viagra order viagra from mexico the ultimate herbal viagra ledi viagra buy viagra next day shipping viagra power v8 puede tomar viagra una mujer viagra cork original viagra in india viagra four hours viagra poshel von viagra for seniors free viagra sample packs viagra for women liquid viagra kaufen europa viagra biologiya viagra stiff comprar viagra en argentina sin receta crushing viagra canada store viagra viagra internetapotheke where can i buy viagra in hyderabad buy viagra abu dhabi nina turner viagra viagra pharmacy south africa viagra hard after ejaculation hvordan fungerer viagra viagra sale shops results of viagra photos cheapest viagra soft tabs expired viagra safe i want to order viagra can i snort viagra viagra kopen nederland counteract viagra viagra farmacie pret viagra maroc vente noi ban viagra is canadian viagra real tijuana viagra where to buy viagra shops delhi buy cheap real viagra viagra over the counter ireland forum viagra pour femme viagra at super viagra pfizer pakistan viagra e bebida alcoolica viagra effects on heart ingredients of viagra natural wholesale viagra from canada alli diet supplement order heartgard online buy cailis lipitor allergic reaction eretile dysfunction viagra vente libre en france is viagra generic yet is viagra good for men viagra flowers viagra introduction can buy viagra online australia what colour are viagra pills can you buy viagra from walmart tamsulosin viagra viagra time period is viagra available in uk viagra any good viagra and flowers viagra kerala natural viagra over counter viagra pareri viagra safe for young men viagra pfizer sales tomar viagra de joven venta de pastillas de viagra vigrx plus viagra tac dung cua thuoc viagra viagra ringtone what are the dangers of taking viagra viagra blister boots chemists viagra buy viagra online best sites dostinex viagra les 11 commandements viagra viagra 5000 viagra acheter online female equivalent of viagra statt viagra walgreens viagra generic viagra canberra viagra and diving cost of one viagra pill buying viagra from canada no prescription viagra australia review can i buy viagra in the philippines printable viagra coupon la viagra es peligrosa viagra online tesco viagra can kill you viagra memphis long term side effects viagra use generic viagra phone viagra price new zealand main ingredient in viagra how old you have to be to buy viagra viagra en vente libre en france how much viagra do you take viagra prescription vancouver viagra natural ingredients wholesale viagra from china venta de viagra peru what are the risks of taking viagra how much does viagra cost cvs viagra army healthcare viagra insurance viagra real stories viagra and ghb ayurvedic viagra in india viagra tablets name in india viagra for girls to get mood viagra side effects eyes natural remedies viagra para q es el viagra viagra baseball pasteque viagra acheter viagra en ligne au canada buy viagra in manchester cheapest viagra mastercard what is the opposite of viagra viagra klip acquisto viagra in svizzera buy viagra in norway viagra like herbs viagra und kokain what is taking viagra like viagra introduced viagra pastillas azules home remedies viagra viagra and ace inhibitors enlarged prostate viagra can girls use viagra obama viagra get viagra free uk comprar viagra linea taking viagra alcohol baris manco viagra revatio vs. viagra acquisto viagra svizzera how to prepare viagra viagra t shirts effects of viagra on the heart viagra expired safe viagra and alpha blockers viagra spain prescription viagra effects on the heart pfizer viagra patent expiration why viagra does not work for me viagra pour femme forum enlarged prostate and viagra cuanto tiempo dura el efecto del viagra best price viagra us buy viagra no prescription needed viagra in nederland kopen viagra stories of success viagra in northern ireland online doctor viagra prescription viagra temperature is viagra available in australia viagra 100 mg too much origins of viagra generic viagra at walgreens viagra super active plus online viagra generico legale buy viagra hyderabad pfizer viagra 25 viagra ohne probleme is buying viagra online illegal buying viagra in south africa viagra stop stop stop mp3 get best results viagra chemical structure viagra viagra lifestyle high blood pressure medication viagra brazilian generic viagra is viagra safe for young men vente viagra maroc viagra 50 mg vs 100 mg forum prix du viagra order viagra legally viagra from india reviews stone viagra order viagra mexico online doctor prescription viagra do you need a prescription to get viagra generic viagra forum uk viagra for sale singapore best sites to buy viagra online viagra acid reflux viagra for sale over counter viagra hypertension treatment can you buy viagra over the counter in the usa free trial viagra coupons viagra uk ebay viagra in kerala viagra frankreich kaufen walk in clinic viagra sustancia activa del viagra viagra frankreich rezeptfrei viagra dejstvo generic viagra shipping canada viagra birmingham uk viagra long term use side effects viagra hasznalata generic viagra in us pharmacies is it illegal to order viagra online free generic viagra no prescription viagra soft tabs forum how much does a viagra tablet cost real viagra stories order viagra from canadian pharmacy comprar viagra peru natural viagra in australia viagra feeling viagra help performance anxiety sublingual generic viagra viagra discography viagra stop stop mp3 does viagra stop premature ejaculation best place buy viagra uk how long does it take viagra to start working viagra cost ireland 100 mg viagra too much buy generic viagra online india right dose viagra over the counter viagra like pills viagra work with alcohol taking two viagra viagra online american pharmacy i took 2 viagra online viagra bestellen forum como comprar pastillas viagra buy viagra online mexico can you buy viagra over the counter usa cheapest generic viagra india usar viagra es malo viagra enlargement pills viagra northern ireland herbal supplements for viagra alternative zu viagra rezeptfrei colour of viagra pills high blood pressure medication and viagra how do viagra pills look like buy viagra london uk viagra from boots chemists viagra experiences forum opposite of viagra viagra methamphetamine forum viagra online kaufen viagra vs revatio what happens after viagra viagra off label kanye west stay up viagra buy viagra hanoi viagra for hypertension treatment generic viagra uk reviews viagra sale online uk temps d'action du viagra viagra meat buy viagra no prescription usa long term side effects of viagra use why does viagra cause blue vision how long does it viagra to take effect is 100mg viagra safe viagra what dosage should i take is viagra 100 mg too much buying viagra chemist reliable source for viagra compare viagra uk countries viagra over counter ordering viagra online in canada power v8 viagra viagra at home using fruits where to buy viagra in manchester viagra ban o dau viagra equivalent over the counter viagra jokes humour cheapest female viagra is it easy to get a prescription for viagra viagra sheffield viagra pdr is it legal to buy viagra from canada online viagra oslo natural sources of viagra ordering viagra online canada viagra how soon does it work viagra 100 mg fiyat stop stop stop viagra mp3 viagra commercial actress viagra for young men safe donde conseguir viagra sin receta buy viagra auckland viagra online florida who can not take viagra buying viagra in the philippines tesco viagra stores la viagra es mala is it legal to buy viagra online from canada best male viagra meaning of viagra in hindi viagra kostenlos probe buying viagra from chemist zusammensetzung von viagra buying viagra women moodle viagra viagra aus indien bestellen best place to buy viagra online generic viagra peru venta natural viagra ingredients viagra 100 mg side effects vente viagra au maroc viagra with methamphetamine free samples of viagra from pfizer im up like viagra buying viagra melbourne cheapest viagra on internet can a women take mens viagra what is the female equivalent of viagra liquid viagra in uk how long does it take for viagra to take effect buy generic viagra online us printable coupon for viagra real viagra usa what happens if you take viagra and you don't need it how to order viagra from mexico viagra is awesome efectos de tomar viagra viagra over the counter countries viagra singapore sale cheap generic viagra reviews buying women viagra how long does viagra take to effect women who take viagra for men viagra side effects on eyes buy viagra cheapest price when was viagra introduced viagra ebay uk canadian non prescription viagra cheap legal viagra much does viagra cost cvs cork viagra how easy is it to get a prescription for viagra the opposite of viagra why does viagra not work for me free sample packs of viagra buy viagra norway la viagra del cerebro viagra sales figures viagra and cardiovascular disease viagra 50 mg review what does viagra cost per pill symptoms of viagra overdose cuanto tiempo dura el efecto viagra natural ingredients in viagra safe online viagra ordering viagra ghb viagra available in uk does viagra kill order viagra canadian pharmacy wholesale viagra china viagra vikipedija prix viagra forum viagra and zantac should insurance companies pay for viagra viagra tabs 50mg buy viagra in abu dhabi dangers of using viagra cheap viagra no prescription canada v is for viagra the remixes why we use viagra viagra online spain cheap viagra pills for sale viagra patent expiration in canada something like viagra who has bought viagra online buy viagra online without perscription buy viagra uk pharmacy viagra origins viagra manufacturer in india canadian pharmacy reviews viagra viagra for sale 50mg viagra for infants cheap viagra eu non-prescription substitute for viagra acquistare viagra in svizzera viagra worldwide sales 2010 cheap generic viagra uk online viagra shop in melbourne cheap viagra spam viagra und betablocker how old do you have to be to buy viagra how can viagra kill you buy viagra egypt usual dose of viagra viagra price europe safe sites to buy viagra pasteque et viagra viagra statins sildenafil citrate generic viagra 100mg tesco viagra cost viagra for young guys viagra super cost of viagra at tesco buy 1 viagra pill what happens when a man takes viagra viagra makes me last longer viagra 100mg 12 venta de viagra en farmacias sin receta viagra and tamsulosin viagra in malaysia where to get viagra diving viagra prezzo italia main ingredient of viagra best generic viagra reviews south korea viagra viagra stores in pakistan what year did viagra come out names of viagra pills medco viagra viagra main ingredient best viagra prices - uk how long does viagra take to start working hefner viagra buy priligy viagra viagra sales no prescription viagra and extacy voltaren viagra viagra ultrafarma boss viagra where to buy viagra in auckland nebenwirkungen viagra 100 generico viagra barato viagra how long does it take to take effect safe websites to buy viagra viagra to help with performance anxiety viagra income viagra y presion alta buy safe viagra canada uk suppliers of generic viagra viagra tired venta de viagra para mujeres acheter viagra au quebec viagra gel thailand acid reflux viagra viagra pfizer patent expiration viagra absorption ghb and viagra como comprar viagra en peru canadian pharmacy viagra reviews how long does viagra take effect acheter viagra femme side effects of viagra in urdu viagra women pink pill onde posso comprar viagra viagra for women oral gel viagra achat viagra pas cher venda viagra generico do i need prescription for viagra in us viagra 50 vs 100 mg viagra sold at stores professional viagra reviews viagra patentschutz ayurvedic viagra india viagra is amazing female viagra equivalent viagra mississauga comprar pastillas viagra viagra billigst viagra gelato viagra in india mumbai viagra non prescription substitute generic viagra suppliers uk viagra patent expiration canada how easy is it to get a viagra prescription what is it like taking viagra is it good to take viagra wie sehen viagra aus viagra walk in clinic viagra colchicine viagra no consultation viagra sale in singapore name of viagra for men reputable online pharmacy viagra cheap generic viagra pills online betablocker und viagra zantac viagra over the counter viagra countries viagra dilantin generic viagra reviews uk viagra kaufen apotheke ohne rezept viagra head office in toronto canada viagra stone vente de viagra au maroc viagra pour femme pharmacie what dosage of viagra should i take what will happen if girls take viagra viagra tablets in bangalore buy viagra edinburgh panda viagra viagra and stuffy nose viagra farmacias ahumada president viagra venta viagra femenino when will viagra be over the counter buy viagra from egypt acheter viagra online health shop viagra viagra fass viagra arrhythmia wo kann ich viagra rezeptfrei kaufen viagra how long before it works costo del viagra en peru viagra canadians cheapest herbal viagra tomar viagra joven viagra and enlarged prostate is generic viagra available in usa original viagra uk viagra substitute non prescription venta de viagra femenino generic viagra sublingual generic chewable viagra viagra side effects in urdu venta de pastillas viagra chinese viagra uk metabolism of viagra buy generic viagra online mastercard buying viagra safely cost of viagra in ireland how much does 100mg viagra cost comprar viagra lima viagra sold stores legales viagra is expired viagra safe viagra high blood pressure medication best place to buy generic viagra online where to buy viagra in ottawa viagra 50 mg versus 100 mg cheap generic viagra online uk viagra soft tabs overnight names of viagra for women viagra stomach upset viagra allopurinol statins and viagra viagra hemorrhoids ordering viagra online safe billig viagra rezeptfrei pictures of viagra results what does viagra do for females can you buy viagra over the counter in the us best selling viagra order viagra in europe reliable pharmacy viagra viagra on line argentina natural viagra pills viagra seniors safe websites buy viagra viagra costume viagra lloyds chemist female viagra canadian comprar viagra 100 dangers of taking viagra viagra alo mam buying viagra in uae why do guys take viagra company that makes viagra viagra costo en peru how to get free viagra uk el viagra lo puede tomar una mujer countries where viagra is over the counter get free viagra online forum viagra online bestellen effect of viagra on heart viagra order review quarter viagra illegal to order viagra online viagra for women 2011 viagra price hyderabad can i take viagra everyday generic viagra in ireland el viagra requiere receta medica viagra on ebay uk viagra supply uk viagra tamsulosin viagra pour femme en pharmacie sustancia activa viagra another name for viagra posso comprar viagra generic viagra uk forum viagra deutschland apotheke viagra para la eyaculacion precoz best online viagra australia reputable online pharmacy for viagra how to counteract viagra hvordan virker viagra viagra avec ordonnance how much does viagra 100mg cost viagra for men canada viagra concentration where can i buy viagra in manchester effects of viagra on heart viagra enlarged prostate viagra et ejaculation precoce viagra once a day viagra how it works how long before buying viagra germany viagra and macular degeneration comprar viagra sin receta en argentina viagra side effects urdu dosificacion de viagra viagra alpha blockers what would happen if girls take viagra viagra over the counter london generic viagra in canada is it legal how to tell counterfeit viagra i hate viagra viagra naturale farmacia rezeptfreie alternative viagra different kinds of viagra what company makes viagra do you have to have prescription for viagra free pfizer viagra samples web pharmacy viagra herbal viagra for sale viagra femenino venta what is the right dose of viagra bad side effect of viagra does viagra have side effect viagra sans ordonnances france viagra cambodia buy viagra ottawa comprar viagra en santiago year viagra came out viagra atenolol interaction side effects of long term viagra use ace inhibitors viagra viagra copd viagra houston texas viagra kopen apotheek viagra pro and cons best place to buy viagra uk viagra kaufen ausland buy viagra tablets india acheter viagra quebec biaxin viagra viagra libido women can you buy viagra in walmart good cheap viagra what age can i take viagra viagra canada patent expiration viagra liquid for women site de vente de viagra viagra nausea viagra tablets name india viagra funciona mesmo fake prescription for viagra methamphetamine viagra 100mg viagra vs 50 mg cheap real viagra online viagra recommendations pdr viagra how long viagra takes to work lloyds chemist viagra price of viagra in new zealand viagra bc canada effexor xr viagra viagra price in europe viagra manly viagra prices new zealand viagra wholesale canada age of viagra users viagra pour femme prix viagra allergic reaction offshore viagra viagra pills for sale cheap viagra documentary 1000 ways to die viagra generic alternatives to viagra what happens if you take viagra and don't need it viagra aurochem viagra stop mp3 cose il viagra viagra ohne rezept 25mg viagra in delhi shops le iene viagra girls using viagra viagra and nasal spray viagra clock cheapest viagra super active viagra generico foro pfizer viagra free samples viagra 25mg uk generic viagra in nz overdose viagra symptoms o viagra faz mal a saude best prices viagra uk what is the meaning of viagra in hindi alternative to viagra for women venta de viagra natural can i buy viagra in hong kong viagra 100 mg sale generico do viagra ems reliable viagra source pfizer viagra pakistan order viagra europe cozumel viagra viagra for enlarged prostate viagra biaxin viagra increase libido viagra in riyadh how to get best results from viagra questions about generic viagra is it easy to get a viagra prescription el viagra del cerebro using viagra without erectile dysfunction buying viagra philippines online doctor prescription for viagra buying viagra in germany como comprar viagra sin receta en argentina viagra coupon printable viagra 150 mg dosage rush limbaugh viagra scandal viagra generika online bestellen get generic viagra prescription online viagra apotheke deutschland viagra generic alternatives buy viagra priligy viagra for sale over the counter gout viagra comprare viagra svizzera where to buy viagra manchester viagra infants cheap generic viagra online pharmacy viagra dosage 150 mg do not take viagra if quarter of viagra anything stronger than viagra melhor generico do viagra how long until viagra works can i buy viagra online in canada buy viagra now uk viagra free prescription uk viagra belgien pfizer patent expiration viagra viagra dosificacion viagra hq chanson sur le viagra how long it takes for viagra to work buy real viagra cheap over the counter viagra in stores viagra hyderabad price nasal spray viagra viagra for sale in shops viagra serve ricetta opposite to viagra viagra zantac buying viagra in bangkok australian herbal viagra viagra falls the play viagra ineffective side effects of long term use of viagra generic viagra price comparison viagra china wholesale viagra in islam non prescription viagra alternatives buy viagra online wiki how successful is viagra viagra untuk wanita generic viagra shipping to canada women liquid viagra long term viagra use side effects viagra in cambodia buy viagra tijuana viagra young men safe viagra tesco online over the counter pills like viagra viagra sildenafil 50mg side effects viagra bedienungsanleitung viagra blog women viagra alternative women is it legal to get viagra online viagra stores in delhi viagra experience forum where is the best place to buy viagra in uk viagra and arrhythmia buy herbal viagra australia overdose of viagra symptoms generic viagra oral jelly copd viagra viagra for women cream over counter viagra equivalent do you have to have a prescription for viagra viagra pricing canada allergic reaction to viagra best type of viagra cost viagra ireland where to buy viagra in tijuana how long does it take for viagra to start working viagra retina viagra safe young men viagra webmd viagra high street 25mg viagra uk buy viagra online free shipping viagra in dhaka viagra how many hours viagra cuanto tiempo hace efecto viagra temps d'action viagra y otras viagra en ligne pas cher can i take viagra every day how to get viagra in malaysia viagra vente libre france viagra roche viagra improve performance cialis tab 20mg how frequently can you take cialis effect of cialis on blood pressure cialis 20 mg in usa prix cialis au maroc how long before sex do i take cialis tomar cialis y alcohol side effect of cialis use cialis as blood pressure medication brand cialis online no prescription comprar cialis en usa how long does cialis take effect achat cialis belgique can cialis lower blood pressure donde comprar cialis en mexico metoprolol cialis generic cialis at walmart buy cialis vancouver is it legal to order cialis online cialis and blood pressure medicine how often should you take cialis cialis grapefruit effect cialis 5 mg apotheke order cialis daily comprar cialis en argentina cialis cardura cialis action mechanism do i need a prescription for cialis in canada how long does it take cialis to take effect cardura cialis cialis once a day 5 mg when to take cialis 10mg what to expect with cialis cialis 15 mg much does cialis cost walmart cialis 5 mg once a day cialis songs commercials discount cialis soft tabs cialis vision side effects safe place to buy cialis buying cialis mexico cialis inhibitors generic cialis for women cialis blood pressure medicine what is the usual dose for cialis cialis bluthochdruck cialis mechanism of action cialis and blood pressure medications what does cialis do to women comment prendre du cialis precio de pastillas cialis efectos cialis 20 mg cialis throat inderal cialis cialis strategy cialis original lilly cialis 20 mg vs 10mg cialis express shipping cialis moins cher en france cialis and peyronies cuanto cuesta el cialis en mexico generic cialis online shop how long does cialis stay in system cialis generic walmart does generic cialis look like cialis young men side effects cialis farmacias guadalajara cialis 10mg review cialis amlodipine directions for cialis use alcohol cialis interaction cialis 20 mg paypal when does cialis go generic why bathtubs in cialis ads cialis precio oficial cialis ad 2011 how safe is generic cialis from india cialis ohne rezept holland cialis en argentina comprar cutting cialis in half cialis 10mg kosten gde kupiti cialis how long does cialis take to take effect ordering cialis from canada overdose cialis symptoms is it illegal to buy cialis online where to buy cialis in dubai long term effects of cialis use cialis niacin cialis generique en ligne what does cialis cost in canada precio cialis 20 mg en farmacia cialis canada mail order cialis and metoprolol cialis and psa commander du cialis en france daily cialis bph cialis 20 mg efectos how long is cialis in your system price cialis pakistan cialis daily order buy cialis dubai cialis how long does it take to take effect generic cialis trial low cost cialis online tadalafil cialis precio illegal to buy cialis online cialis with beta blockers cialis dubai uae pastilla cialis precio cialis 100mg. online how much is cialis per pill cialis black canada cialis case study donde comprar cialis mexico 100 mg cialis tadalafil cialis alcohol interaction how long does cialis stay in the system cialis 20mg discount cialis sold in canada cialis price canadian pharmacy do you need a prescription to buy cialis cialis dosage info cialis once a day price 1 a day cialis where to buy cialis in ontario legit cialis online cialis ohne rezept apotheke cialis use instructions cialis commercial actors posologia cialis 20 mg get cialis sample cialis dosage take brand cialis uk para que es cialis 20 mg cialis 5 mg ohne rezept comprar cialis barcelona cialis cause back pain cialis forum doctissimo ranbaxy cialis cialis gay men amlodipine and cialis prix du cialis au maroc cialis maroc prix tadalafil cialis side effects comprar cialis en barcelona cialis working time cialis athletes cialis fedex delivery cialis packung maker of cialis buying canadian cialis cialis lilly original achat cialis paypal cialis online review online pharmacy cialis commercial songs cialis and lorazepam cialis frequency how much is cialis daily use should i buy cialis online cialis soft reviews cialis made usa ordering cialis canada cheap brand name cialis cialis meals buy cialis professional cheap cialis side effects for young men cialis price walmart pharmacy cialis lloyds how long cialis stay in your system cialis neuropathy cialis no prescription next day best online cialis canada cialis usual dose mexico pharmacy cialis cialis comprar argentina acquisto cialis originale cialis adverse reactions amlodipine cialis brand name cialis cheap dove acquistare cialis on line side effects of cialis 5mg cheap brand cialis online cialis pro reviews where to buy cialis in sydney buy cialis in vancouver cialis yellow acquistare cialis in contrassegno naproxen and cialis discount cialis professional achat de cialis en belgique cialis and alcohol interaction cialis for young men side effects where to buy cialis in vancouver cialis pro review precio de cialis lilly woman takes cialis daily cialis vs 36 hour order internet cialis cialis back pain cause cialis long term use effects cialis generico senza ricetta cialis holland apotheke cialis dosages 10 mg cialis directions for taking cialis online pharmacy review long term use of cialis effects cialis mail order in canada cialis made in usa cialis argentina precios dove acquistare cialis online cialis cape town cialis peak time order brand name cialis doctors prescription for cialis cialis germania cialis mail order canada buy cialis in ontario 5mg cialis side effects directions taking cialis online cialis scams cialis regular dose cuanto cuesta cialis en mexico cialis in der schweiz cialis directions use cialis and gout cialis venta en chile precio de pastilla cialis cialis what to expect percocet and cialis directions on taking cialis long term effects cialis use cialis brand online no prescription wo kann man cialis kaufen se puede comprar cialis sin receta generic cialis plus cialis and indigestion cialis 1 a day generic cialis dangers cialis side effects young men will cialis lower blood pressure long term use cialis effects cialis mexico pharmacy safe dose of cialis order cialis on the internet cialis free trial online real cialis from canada cialis daily for bph cialis loss of vision cialis 10 mg farmacia how much is cialis for daily use best canadian pharmacy for cialis cialis make you bigger generic cialis no rx yellow cialis comprar cialis andorra precio importing cialis cialis 36 hour vs daily micardis and cialis buy fda cialis comment prendre le cialis comprar cialis argentina cialis pro online lilly cialis uk cialis any good buying cialis in mexico how much does cialis cost walmart cialis on empty stomach lorazepam cialis cialis 5 mg side effects original cialis lilly cialis beta blockers mail order cialis canada cialis lilly uk cialis good for you cialis in abu dhabi cialis tratamiento acquisto cialis in farmacia cialis dosagem illegal buy cialis online cialis price pakistan cialis micardis cialis apotheke holland mens health cialis cialis online fast shipping cialis cycle cialis super active plus online cialis daily vs cialis 36 hour cialis doses recommended buy cialis ontario cialis 20mg india cialis cena apteka precio pastillas cialis free cialis trial online can cialis be split in half cialis bei bluthochdruck cialis professional uk cialis cough cialis name blood pressure medication cialis cialis on cycle generic cialis cheap india precio cialis lilly cialis 10mg side effects how to get cialis sample can i take cialis every day cheap cialis europe cialis directions for use cialis instructions use generic cialis illegal cialis 1800 buy generic cialis online usa cialis nausea free trial cialis online online pharmacy for cialis review cialis muscle aches best website to buy cialis acquisto cialis in contrassegno acquisto cialis senza ricetta side effects of cialis tadalafil cialis 20g cialis comment le prendre cialis tadalafil prix cialis sales in canada cialis 4 hours where to buy liquid cialis buy cialis germany cialis 20 mg posologia cialis apotheke ohne rezept cialis mode d'emploi order cialis australia symptoms of cialis overdose cialis dosage when to take cialis abu dhabi cialis prix au maroc best canadian pharmacy cialis cialis side effects vision cialis and percocet cialis for men what does it do cialis soft generico female cialis forum cialis erfahrungen forum buying cialis from mexico daily cialis for bph cialis tadalafil precio beta blocker and cialis cialis lilly preis buy cialis sydney cialis beta blocker cialis daily bph cialis moins cher en pharmacie cialis internet pharmacy cialis usos cialis 5mg pills doctors prescription cialis cialis 100mg online how long before sex should i take cialis 15 mg cialis cialis daily vs. cialis 36 hour cialis turkiye cialis directions taking cialis pills effects cialis market share cialis internet canada cheapest cialis tablets buy cialis online in europe levitra cost walgreens impotence levitra levitra in ireland is levitra generic available levitra 10 mg generico levitra generika bestellen levitra with grapefruit juice levitra non generic grapefruit juice and levitra levitra class levitra 10 mg tablet levitra fake levitra bayer buy discount levitra canada levitra generico italia pharmacy prices levitra levitra interactions cost of levitra at walgreens buy levitra united states quanto costa levitra farmacia levitra 20mg kosten levitra medikament levitra function levitra kaufen deutschland prezzo levitra 5 mg levitra price uk buying levitra canada levitra 30 tablet levitra grapefruit juice vendita levitra online levitra 20 mg fiyat levitra half life levitra pregnancy levitra prezzo bayer levitra tabletas buy online levitra in usa levitra is not working generic levitra work buy generic levitra uk buy levitra without rx precio levitra bucodispersable levitra without ed levitra spam levitra 5mg alcohol walmart pharmacy levitra prospecto de levitra levitra and grapefruit juice levitra consumer reviews levitra stories grapefruit juice levitra levitra prescription prices levitra customer reviews levitra 10mg kosten lowest price generic levitra levitra user comments pharmacy prices for levitra lisinopril and levitra acquisto levitra generico levitra symptoms long term effects of levitra levitra best results levitra weight loss buying levitra from canada buying levitra in canada levitra testosterone levitra generika ohne rezept levitra prescription cost order levitra online no prescription buy levitra bayer order levitra uk acquisto levitra on line buy cheap levitra no prescription levitra new zealand levitra 20 mg precios levitra quanto costa in farmacia generic vs brand name levitra best results with levitra levitra 20 mg cheap interactions with levitra levitra for less is generic levitra available levitra not working levitra 5 mg prezzo comprare levitra online levitra 200 quanto costa levitra in farmacia levitra generico india levitra generico 10 mg half life of levitra cost of levitra per pill levitra pharmacy prices buy online levitra usa levitra generico acquisto levitra and pregnancy generic levitra dapoxetine liquid levitra buy bayer levitra best results for levitra walgreens levitra cost levitra uk price comprar levitra sin receta erection pills viagra explain viagra extasy and viagra female viagra lotion free sample of viagra without prescription free sample viagra without prescription free viagra samples from pfizer free viagra woman funny picture viagra genaric cialis generic cialis cheapest lowest price generic cialis uk online pharmacy generic versions of cialis generic viagra 16 generic viagra woman gout and cialis guide to online viagra hemorrhoids viagra honest place to buy viagra how to get viagra in philippines identify cialis importation viagra india viagra cialis vicodin indigestion viagra indigestion with viagra injecting viagra instant cialis interfere with viagra kamagra pills effects kitchen viagra legal cialis no prescription lowest price for brand cialis lowest price viagra brand lowest price viagra uk macular degeneration viagra multiple orgasms with cialis name buy viagra text buy viagra nokia n72 buy viagra online non generic cialis from canada online viagra without prescription paypal order 50mg viagra order cialis online a href order daily cialis order viagra international order viagra pay with paypal outdated viagra pattaya kamagra pill splitting cialis stars using viagra price of viagra in hyderabad q online cialis